the promenade at the time?â
âWe know one or two. Our man unfortunately let one get away.â
John Moore told Carolus of Sitwellâs observations, including his meeting with Lobbin, whom Moore described as a very good chap.
âWeâve traced the woman with large feet, and her husband. She certainly would look rather mannish beside him at night. Their nameâs Bullamy and theyâre visitors to the town. We also know the man Lobbin, a local newsagent. But we canât trace a man Sitwell sent to the phone. Small, fat and muffled up is all I can get from him. Sitwellâs a keen young man and annoyed with himself for not having seen the man properly and asked his name. He was so anxious to get someone to put a call through that he let this go. He remembers a young man without a hat or overcoat whom he saw on his second visit to the promenade. There are also a few people whom Sitwell saw earlier, but Iâm only giving you the gist of the thing now. The real point seems to me that none of Rafterâs family, no one in fact who could have the smallest motive so far as we know, was seen on the promenade that evening.
âUnless one of the two unidentified ones, the fat muffled man or the youth, belonged to the family.â
âExactly. Weâre checking on that, of course.â
âHad the body been robbed?â
âNot unless it was some special object. Rafter had seven pounds in his pocket-case and a good watch.â
âHave another drink, John. Mrs Stick wonât be ready for us yet and I want to hear about the family.â
âThanks. First thereâs his elder brother Bertrand. About fifty, quiet, apparently quite unperturbed about the whole thing. Heâs a widower with a pleasant flat overlooking the sea. Good war recordâtemporary Colonel. Make no bones about it, he hoped never to see his brother again and truly believed him dead.â
âLive alone?â
âThere was a rather handsome girl there when I went, referred to as âmy secretaryâ.â
âThen?â
âAn unmarried sister. Emma Rafter. Horsey type. Cheerful, rather downright. She seems almost amused at being questioned. Then thereâs another sister with two sons, one grown up, a Mrs Dalbinney. Living apart from her husband but not divorced. A bit
grande dame
but apparently quite an ordinary sort of matron.â
âWhat about the grown-up son?â
âI havenât met him yet. I gather heâs clever. I believe the younger son, a boy of fifteen or so, is in your school here.â
âI never know their names,â admitted Carolus. âIs that all?â
âThere is another brother, the only one, it seems, who does any work. Heâs a solicitor in Bawdon, our county town. Wife younger than he is and three small children.â
âNot a very promising lot, John. But I see your point. Motiveâs the only wear. Can they all âaccount for their movementsâ, as they say, at the time of the crime?â
âOh yes. They were quite good-natured about it. Spoke as though they were indulging me in a whim when Iasked them. Bertrand had gone to bed. Emma and Mrs Dalbinney went together to the pictures and afterwards back to Mrs Dalbinneyâs flat for a nightcap. Emma stayed the night there as they were both alone. I havenât see the solicitor yet. He had been to see his sister in Selby that afternoon. I feel sure heâll be able to say exactly where he was.â
âYouâre not regarding these as alibis, are you?â
âNo. I havenât got so far. There would have to be a great deal of checking on them before we did that. But they sound perfectly reasonable.â
âHave you tried to find anyone else with a motive for killing Ernest Rafter?â
âWeâre going into that now. All his movements since landing. A reportâs coming through from the Australian police, too. It may point to