someone else. But he had come to the town to see his family.â
âYes. Itâs very, very tricky. From what youâve already learned about him, would you say that Rafter might have been blackmailing anyone?â
âNot, strictly speaking, from what Iâve learnt. But it seems to me that a man who would collaborate almost voluntarily, before there was any sign of torture or anything of the sort, would do pretty well anything.â
âI agree. I think we should know a great deal more about Ernest. The family doesnât sound promising.â
âYouâve got no suggestions, Carolus?â
âOn what youâve told me, none at all. But I have a feeling that I may be spending Christmas in Selby-on-Sea.â
Moore was silent.
âYou know,â he said presently. âIf you do come youâre on your own. This is a private chat, but if youâre in the town you get no information from us. It has to be like that. I canât discuss the thing with you again.â
âOf course I realize that.â
âOn the other hand I donât deny I shall be glad if you do come. We canât work together but this is a case where Iâd be glad of one of your startling theories. Iâve got noneat all at present, startling or otherwise. In fact thereâs only one thing certain in this case.â
âAnd that?â
âIt was murder. In other cases Iâve tackled it could be suicide or an accident.
This was murder.â
âYes, Mrs Stick?â said Carolus, for the little woman had come quietly into the room.
She glared at the two men, her lips tight and her small figure drawn up taut.
âYour dinner, sir,â she brought herself to say.
Neither Carolus nor John discussed the matter which interested them till they were back in the study with their brandy and cigars.
Then Carolus saidââYou mentioned some people seen by your man. Any of them interesting?â
Moore smiled.
âInteresting? You donât know Selby in winter. Itâs a parish pump sort of place. He saw four people in all, at least according to his report, and knew them all quite well. There was the Vicar of one of the townâs four churches, the Reverend Theo Morsell and his wife.â
Carolus sighed.
âThereâs always a parson,â he said. âWho else?â
âCharacter called Bodger. Sort of professional Old Salt. Takes the visitors out in his boat in the summer. Troublesome but nothing serious known against him. Little bits of trouble, I believe. If weâre going to be far-fetched I would add that his son died on the Burma Road. But he says that he had never heard of Ernest Rafter and I donât for a moment disbelieve him. There was also a man called Stringer, an assistant in an ironmongerâs shop.â
âI must say I donât envy you, John. And thereâs been plenty of publicity given to the case, I donât quite see why. The coal hammer, perhaps. Itâs always some detail like that which appeals to public imagination. Theyâll leave it in your hands?â
âI think so. But Iâve got to produce what are oddlycalled âresultsâ fairly soon. When does your school break up?â
âOn December 19. Early this year. Iâll be there on the 20th.â
âYouâd better stay at the Hydro. Itâs supposed to be the best hotel.â
âWhat about the Queen Victoria? Thatâs where Rafter stayed, isnât it?â
âYes. Itâs possible. Old-fashioned commercial.â
âItâll suit me. Iâll book a room.â
Carolus returned once more to the matter of the murder by asking a direct question on policy.
âWhat line are you working on, John? You must have the beginnings of a theory.â
âScarcely even that. But itâs obvious that the murderer could not have been at that shelter by chance, or have met Rafter there by