and theyâre contentious, which is why the probate judge ordered the estate liquidated.â
âThatâs different from the will?â he asked.
âYes and no. The will had a provision where the heirs could take turns selecting items from the house, but one of the sons said he just wanted the money and the other two wanted the same item first and then there are the grandchildren who wouldnât know Sheraton from Shinola. The judge tried, but after two hours, he couldnât take the bickering and asked me â as the executrix â to go ahead and liquidate.â
âOut of curiosity,â he asked, âwhich is the piece that the two sons wanted?â
âIâll show you,â Ada said, and we followed her into the living room.
There, behind a hyperactive philodendron and a potted palm, hung a gilt-framed painting of three women in Victorian dresses and picture hats at a seaside picnic.
âOh my!â Tolliver stared at the painting. He stepped over the plants to get a closer look. He ran the tips of his fingers gently across the surface of the large canvas. He pulled out a pair of half glasses and studied the red-paint signature in the corner. âUnless they are in a huge hurry, we should consign this to either Christieâs or Sothebyâs.â
âWhat is it?â I asked, having never really given much thought to this particular painting hidden behind Evieâs indoor jungle.
He sighed. âItâs an extremely desirable work of American Impressionism. The painter was a man named Childe Hassam. He was part of the artist community in Old Lyme, so itâs not unheard of for one of his canvases to turn up like this. Still, this appears to be in pristine condition and was painted at the height of his popularity; itâs spectacular. It has everything you want in a Hassam painting; beautiful ladies, the beach, gorgeous sky, lots of impasto. To get top dollar, it should go to one of the New York houses.â
âWhatâs it worth?â Ada asked, cutting straight to the heart of the matter.
âHard to say. I wouldnât be surprised if it brought three hundred thousand, maybe more. Itâs clearly the single most valuable thing here.â He smiled in our direction. âUnless you know of any other American masterpieces hidden in the cupboards?â The corners of his eyes crinkled pleasantly and dimples formed in his cheeks.
It was hard not to like him, and I could tell that Ada felt the same. He knew his business, and thus far my antennae hadnât been alerted to any underlying fraud or attempt to put one over.
He finished his inventory, and as he set to leave, he handed each of us a heavy cream-colored card. âYou might want to do something about that painting,â he cautioned. âI donât see a security system, and human nature being what it is, Iâve seen things like that go missing.â
âYou donât think . . .â Ada started.
âIt wouldnât hurt to get an insurance rider and put it in storage. Whether or not you decide to go with us, Iâd be happy to show you how to do that.â
âThatâs good of you,â Ada said. âIâll be in touch either way.â
We shook hands all around and then watched from the doorway as he headed out to a sporty black BMW convertible.
âHe seemed respectable,â I commented.
âFirst of the bunch,â she said, checking the clock. âLetâs put some water on before the next one gets here.â
âYou donât just want to go with Tolliver?â I asked.
She sighed. âIâd love to,â she replied, heading to Evieâs rooster-themed kitchen. âBut if I donât get three quotes, someone is going to raise a fuss. And donât have a fit, but number two is Mildred Potts.â
âYou didnât . . . Oh, Ada, after the auction?â
âI know, but no one was