bodies. But at the talk of Ruthie that had changed to this abject, miserable, uncontrolled grief. It didnât take much imagination to connect the two.
âWeâll conduct a thorough search of both the house and the barns,â she said.
âDo you want me to help?â
She shook her head, almost ashamed of her suspicions. âThe police prefer to do it themselves. Donât worry, please. If Ruthie is here weâll find her.â
Shackleton looked away. âSo he got her too.â
âHe?â
âItâs just a way of sayinâ it.â His voice was choked with emotion. âYou canât imagine a woman doinâ that.â The shock had made his face so white she thought he might faint. âNot that.â
âIâm afraid,â Joanna said wearily, âthereâs nothing in there that excludes a woman. Anyone could have pulled that trigger, Mr Shackleton. Anyone.â
They stood in silence for a moment, then Joanna asked, âThe three of them lived here?â
He nodded. âYeah. Old Aaron, Ruthie and Jack.â
âNo other women?â
Shackleton shook his head. âNo, Mrs Summers had cancer. She died when Jack was just a baby. He were only ten months old. Ruthie brought him up.â He made an attempt at a smile. âProper little mother she were to him.â But then some old memory must have moved through his mind and his face assumed a pained expression. It seemed to Joanna that for some reason this recollection compelled him to defend Ruthie. âShe really did love Jack. She did. I know. She was devoted to her brother. People can say what they like.â
And Joannaâs mind was instantly on the alert, as though pricked by a pin. Shackleton stayed silent for a long time.
âDo you have any idea who could have done this, Mr Shackleton? Had the family any enemies?â
Dave Shackleton shook his head. âMust have been a robbery that went wrong.â
But Joanna didnât think so. âWe will, of course, be searching the house but so far we have seen no sign of ...â She paused. In this house of open doors there would have been no need for forced entry. Anyone could have simply walked in.
Shackleton must have picked up on her train of thoughts. âExactly,â he said. âNo one would have needed to break a window or force a lock. It was so easy. Like I told the big guy.â
âDetective Sergeant Korpanski.â
âYou could walk into Hardacre any time of the day or night.â He looked away, embarrassed.
âThat makes it all the more difficult for us to work out who did.â Joanna hesitated before plunging in with her next question. âTell me, Mr Shackleton. How did they get on with their neighbours?â
There was a movement in front of them, a snorting and bellowing. A herd of cows was careering along the lane towards them. She watched them pass. Behind them a thin, bent figure dressed in navy dungarees was slapping the cows backsides, forcing them into a brisk trot. For that one moment she had a vision of Aaron and Jack Summers doing the identical manoeuvre.
The farmer waved a hand as he passed.
Shackleton nodded briefly and Joanna took up her cue. âSo thatâs Martin Pinkers?â
âThatâs him,â he said, looking uncomfortable. âHe offered to do the milkinâ and ...â He scratched his head. âThey needed doinâ. They was goinâ wild.â He eyed Joanna dubiously. âIt might seem hard and uncaring gettinâ him over here but they need the milk takinâ off. Cowsâ udders fill murder or no murder. Besides Aaron would have wanted it.â
Hard and uncaring getting him over here. Had she imagined the emphasis on the him ?
And if she had not imagined it what vague hostility lay behind it?
She glanced again at the thin man with his hard, boney face and then turned her attention back to Shackleton, knowing one thing