Buttons was on the side, with Stacy holding his reins, of course. In the back were Mr. Johnson and a very unhappy Amanda, who had been forced to be in the photo.
âSmile,â Ms. Walton said, looking though the camera lens.
âFantastic,â Bess grumbled. She leaned over and whispered to George and Nancy, âIn tomorrowâs newspaper there will be a photo of the Clue Crew standing with their three suspects!â
It was Sunday afternoon. The girls were in Nancyâs bedroom, talking while George booted up Nancyâs computer.
âDetective work is fun,â Bess said as she flopped backward onto Nancyâs bed. The purple covers were crinkled beneath her. âBut itâs hard work, too.â She grabbed a pillow and hugged it to her chest.
Nancy got out her purple notebook and flipped through the pages.
âComputerâs ready,â George announced. âI started a new file for this case.â
âGreat.â Nancy looked down at what sheâd written. âWe have three suspects. Stacy Quinn,Mr. Johnson, and Amanda Johnson.â
From over at Nancyâs desk, George stopped typing. âItâs hard to think of them as suspects because we really like all of them. Itâs a bummer to think that one of them is letting Buttons out of the animal pen.â
There was a knock on Nancyâs door.
âCome in,â Nancy called instead of answering the door herself.
âHello, girls,â Hannah said as she walked into the room, carrying a white plastic tray. âWhy are you looking so sad?â
âWe arenât sad,â Nancy answered. âWe just like all our suspects.â
âTake a break,â Hannah said as she set the tray on top of Nancyâs dresser. âI made cookies. Eat. Drink some milk. Things arenât always what they seem. Did you review your clues?â
âNot yet,â Nancy answered. âWe were talking about the suspects first.â
âAfter your snack, check your clues.â Hannah walked to the door. âYou girls know,â shereminded them as she closed the door behind her, âthat good detectives always think about their clues.â
Each girl ate two chocolate cookies and drank a glass of milk. Full and happy, they were ready to get back to work.
âClues,â Nancy said, reading the column in her notebook. âButtons doesnât like hay. There is a lot of hay outside the pen. Then, thereâs the red paint on Buttonsâs hoof.â
Suddenly, Bess sat up on the bed. âI just realized something. Stacy canât be a suspect. The key to the lock is kept in Mr. Johnsonâs house. She doesnât have a way to open the gate.â
âGood thinking,â Nancy cheered. âI think we should go talk to Stacy again. Letâs ask her if sheâs letting the pony out. That way we can cross her off our list for sure.â
As a rule, the girls were only allowed to walk five blocks from Nancyâs house. Luckily, Stacy lived three blocks away.
The girls were there a few minutes later.
George knocked. âWhoâs there?â Stacy asked through the closed door.
âNancy Drew and the Clue Crew,â Nancy replied. Stacy immediately opened the door.
âHi.â Nancy didnât waste any time. âAre you letting Buttons out at night? You said you would keep him if he showed up at you house.â
âSure, Iâd love to keep him, but thatâs just a dream.â Stacy laughed. âButtons belongs to Mr. Johnson and has a good life at the petting zoo. I can visit there any time I want. Sure I wish Buttons lived at my house, but where would I put him? In the living room?â
âHeâd probably enjoy staying in the kitchen,â Bess put in, and all the girls chuckled.
Nancy thought of an important question that Stacy could easily answer. âMrs. Fayne told us that Shetland ponies are different from other ponies.