Why?â
Stacy didnât even pause to think about the answer. She quickly said, âIn many ways Shetlands are more like goats than ponies.â Justthen, Stacyâs mom called from upstairs. âIâd better go. Weâre leaving to visit my grandparents on the other side of town. I have to change into nicer clothes. See ya at school tomorrow.â
Back in Nancyâs bedroom, Bess suggested, âLetâs cross her off the suspect list.â Nancy got out her notebook and put a purple line though Stacyâs name. George deleted her name from the computer file.
âOnly two suspects left,â George remarked. âIf Stacy isnât letting Buttons go, who is?â
Monday morning the phone rang at Nancyâs house. Nancy was already awake and ready for school, even though it wasnât time to leave yet. All night her brain had been working on the mystery. She hadnât slept very well.
Nancy was comparing ponies and goats. Buttons made a neighing sound, like a pony. He was short like a goat, but other than that, he looked like a pony. Goats ate anything. So did Buttons. Except hay. Buttons didnât like hay.
Her head was spinning from thinking so much.
When the phone rang, she decided that since she was up, sheâd answer it.
âHello, Drew residence,â Nancy said politely, just like Hannah had taught her.
âNancy?â It was Bess. âYou arenât going to believe this!â
Nancy glanced at the clock. It was really early. âShould I guess? Because I bet I know why youâre calling. Thereâs a four-legged visitor at your house, right?â
âYes!â Bess confirmed. âButtons is eating our grass! Right now!â
âI wish I had time to come over,â Nancy said. âIt might be early, but Dad would never let me rush over there before school.â
âGeorgeâs mom said no too,â Bess replied.
âDid you look around for clues?â Nancy asked. âLike when we found the paint on his hoof at Georgeâs.â
âOf course,â Bess said. Nancy could imagine Bess looking the pony over, searching for something unusual. âI didnât find anything. Mr. Johnson must have washed off that red paint mark. This morning, nothing looks suspicious.â
âHmmm,â Nancy said, then went silent.
âNancy?â Bess called into the phone. âNancy? Are you still there? Talk to me. I can hear you breathing. Earth to Nancy.â
Suddenly, Nancy snapped out of it. âIâm here. Sorry. I was thinking.â
âThink later,â Bess advised. âIâd better go. Mr. Johnson just arrived to pick Buttons up. Iâll see you at school.â
All day at school, Nancy was thinking about the mystery. She paid attention in class, but between classes and at lunch, she was constantly bumping into stuff, walking into walls, and tripping on the ends of her shoes. By the time recess came, Bess and George were afraid to leave her alone. She might hurt herself.
âOof,â Nancy said as she banged her elbow on the ladder leading up to the monkey bars.
âOkay,â Bess told Nancy. âYouâd better tell us what youâre thinking, because schoolâs almost over and we canât protect you forever.â
âWhy are you protecting me?â Nancy asked, rubbing her sore elbow. She hadnât noticed that Bess and George had been following her around all day.
âWe have to save you from yourself!â George answered. âYour head is stuck at Johnsonâs Petting Zoo.â
âThatâs not such a bad place to be stuck.â Bess smiled. âItâs superfun there. Did you see the article and photographs in todayâs newspaper?â
Just like Ms. Walton had said, there was a full-page article in the paper. Nancy had seen the picture of herself, Bess, and George with Stacy, Mr. Johnson, and Amanda. Next to that, there was also a