smaller picture of Scott riding Buttons.
Bess grinned. âRemember yesterday when Scott was jumping off the hay pretending he was a duck? It was annoying at the time, but now it seems pretty funny.â
âQuack,â said George. âMy brother can be such a spaz sometimes!â
âMaa,â said Bess. âIâm a goat!â She held two fingers like horns on her head. âMaa.â
âQuack, quack.â George responded, flapping her arms and running in circles around Bess and Nancy.
âThatâs it!â Suddenly, Nancyâs eyes grew wide. âThanks to the both of you, I think I just figured out this mystery.â
âWhat did we do?â George stopped quacking.
âHow did we help?â Bess stopped bleating.
âWhat are you doing after school today?â Nancy asked Bess and George.
They didnât have any plans, except homework.
âGood.â Nancy seemed very happy. âDo your homework right away. Iâm going to ask Hannah if sheâll drive us over to the petting zoo.â
âArenât you going to fill us in?â Bess and George asked together.
âLater,â Nancy said as the school bell rang. It was time to go back to class. âMeet me at my house at four oâclock. When we get to the petting zoo, Iâll tell you the answer to the mystery.â
When Nancy, Bess, and George arrived at the petting zoo, Stacy was already there. She was brushing Buttonsâs mane.
Amanda was there too. She was filling the water dishes in the bunny cages.
Nancy went to get Mr. Johnson. She told him she had something important to share.
âWhat is it?â Mr. Johnson asked. âDid you solve the mystery?â
Nancy smiled and said, âI wonât tell until everyone is together.â
They gathered inside the animal pen, under the shaded area.
âI know how Buttons is getting out,â Nancybegan. âAt first I thought maybe Stacy was letting him out, but then, Bess realized that Stacy couldnât possibly get the key to the gate.â
George added, âWe asked Stacy anyway. She said she didnât do it.â
âRight!â Nancy punched the air. âBut Stacy gave us a new clue.â
âI did?â Stacy asked. âI didnât know I gave you a clue.â
âYou said something really important,â Nancy told her. âYou said that Shetlands are like goats.â Stacy smiled. She was glad sheâd been helpful, even if she didnât quite understand.
Nancy turned to Amanda. âWe thought you might be letting Buttons out because if Buttons disappeared, you might get to move back to Hailey Town.â
âI didnât let him out,â Amanda said. âReally. I might not like it here, but I know how much my dad loves the farm. Iâd never do anything to hurt him.â
âNancy,â George looked surprised. âIf Stacyisnât letting Buttons out and Amanda isnât doing it either, thereâs only one suspect left.â
âThatâs right,â Nancy said confidently. âMr. Johnson is letting Buttons out.â
Mr. Johnson gasped. âNo, Iâm not!â
Nancy hurried to explain. âYou arenât doing it on purpose.â She looked over at Stacy. âStacy, will you please tell Mr. Johnson the number one reason why Shetlands are like goats.â
âEasy.â Stacy folded her arms across her chest. âShetland ponies can climb!â
âOh my gosh!â Bess exclaimed. âButtons has been climbing over the fence.â
âExactly,â Nancy said as she walked over to the bale of hay near the fence. âYesterday Scott climbed on the hay pretending to be a goat.â Nancy stepped up on the bale. She swung one leg over the fence. âStacy gave the final clue about Shetlands, and Bess and George reminded me about the first day we came to the petting zoo. There was a goat who had climbed