Where possible, therefore, he replaced supplies such as salt beef and tinned foods with fresh meat, resulting in a âvery salutary change of diet to our crew.â By doing so, Ross also solved the mystery of Arctic survival. Through contact with the locals, he correctly surmised that their diet of fresh meat had antiscorbutic properties, observing that âthe natives cannot subsist without it, becoming diseased and dying under a more meager diet.â As he wrote in his log, âThe ï¬rst salmon of the summer were a medicine which all the drugs in the ship could not replace.â The Inuit had saved John Rossâs hide and those of his crew, and he knew it, though his praise was tempered by characteristic pomposity. They were, he said, âamong the most worthy of all the rude tribes yet known to our voyagers, in whatever part of the world.â It was only in his fourth winter, after he had lost contact with the Inuit and moved north to Somerset Island, where game was scarce and the expedition became dependent upon tinned foods, that scurvy had made a run at the expedition.
Unfortunately, Captain George Back, on his 1836â37 Arctic expedition, failed to learn from Rossâs example. A veteran of three expeditions across the barren lands of northern Canada, two of them under the command of John Franklin, R.N., George Back was by turns ambitious, conceited and utterly charming. An inveterate womanizer, dandy and accomplished watercolourist, Back was a knowingly Byronic ï¬gure who dabbled in poetry and possessed a certain élan, having spent ï¬ve years as a prisoner of war in Revolutionary France.
Back sailed for the Arctic on 14 June 1836, with orders to travel to Repulse Bay, beyond the northwestern reaches of Hudson Bay, then to send sledge parties across the isthmus of the Melville Peninsula (an arm of the American continent) to explore its western coast. The expedition was an appalling failure. Backâs ship, the Terror, like the Victory, was caught in the Arcticâs thrall of relentless ice. At one point it was hurled 40 feet (12 metres) up a cliff face, only to be mauled by an iceberg. Wrote Back: âTo guard against the worst I ordered the provisions and preserved meats, together with various other necessaries, to be got up from below and stowed on deck, so as to be ready at a moment to be thrown on the large ï¬oe alongside.â Men slept in their clothes, ready to abandon ship at a momentâs notice. On some nights, the ice could be heard gently caressing the hull, on others it wailed and pounded against the shipâs sides. At one point the ice reached up alongside to form a cradle, then, after holding the ship tight in the air, the ï¬oe let go its grasp and the vessel plunged into the sea. Back was astonished to glimpse in those moments a mould of the ship âstamped as perfectly as in a die in the walls of ice on either side.â Next, a huge square mass of ice of many tons collapsed, throwing up a wave 30 feet (9 metres) high that rolled over the stricken Terror. George Back:
It was indeed an awful crisis rendered more frightful from the mistiness of the night and the dimness of the moon. The poor ship cracked and trembled violently and no one could say that the next minute would not be her last, and, indeed, his own too, for with her our means of safety would probably perish.
Compounding the desperate situation, there had been a sudden, serious andâto the expeditionâs captain and medical officerâinexplicable onset of illness aboard the Terror within a fortnight of the last live domestic animal being slaughtered on board. Six months into the expedition, Back complained in his journal on 26 December that the crew had been inï¬icted by âperverseness,â âsluggishnessâ and âlistlessness.â
As his men began complaining of debility, Back concluded they were suffering from scurvy. Yet he made no serious