changes represent large effects. A pH drop of 0.1 means the water has become 30 percent more acidic. If present trends continue, surface pH will drop to around 7.8 by 2100. At that point the water will be 150 percent more acidic than it was in 1800.
The acidification that has occurred so far is probably irreversible. Although in theory itâs possible to add chemicals to the sea to counter the effects of the extra CO 2 , as a practical matter, the volumes involved would be staggering; it would take at least two tons of lime, for example, to offset a single ton of carbon dioxide, and the world now emits more than 30 billion tons of CO 2 each year. Meanwhile, natural processes that could counter acidificationâsuch as the weathering of rocks on landâoperate far too slowly to make a difference on a human timescale. Even if CO 2 emissions were somehow to cease today, it would take tens of thousands of years for ocean chemistry to return to its preindustrial condition.
Acidification has myriad effects. By favoring some marine microbes over others, it is likely to alter the availability of key nutrients like iron and nitrogen. For similar reasons it may let more sunlight penetrate the sea surface. By changing the basic chemistry of seawater, acidification is also expected to reduce the waterâs ability to absorb and muffle low-frequency sound by up to 40 percent, making some parts of the ocean noisier. Finally, acidification interferes with reproduction in some species and with the ability of othersâthe so-called calcifiersâto form shells and stony skeletons of calcium carbonate. These last effects are the best documented ones, but whether they will prove the most significant in the long run is unclear.
In 2008 a group of more than 150 leading researchers issued a declaration stating that they were âdeeply concerned by recent, rapid changes in ocean chemistry,â which could within decades âseverely affect marine organisms, food webs, biodiversity, and fisheries.â Warm-water coral reefs are the prime worry. But because carbon dioxide dissolves more readily in cold water, the impact may actually show up first closer to the Poles. Scientists have already documented significant effects on pteropodsâtiny swimming snails that are an important food for fish, whales, and birds in both the Arctic and the Antarctic. Experiments show that pteropod shells grow more slowly in acidified seawater.
Will organisms be able to adapt to the new ocean chemistry? The evidence from Castello Aragonese is not encouraging. The volcanic vents have been pouring CO 2 into the water for at least a thousand years, Hall-Spencer told me when I visited. But the area where the pH is 7.8âthe level that may be reached oceanwide by the end of the centuryâis missing nearly a third of the species that live nearby, outside the vent system. Those species have had âgenerations on generations to adapt to these conditions,â Hall-Spencer said, âyet theyâre not there.
âBecause itâs so important, we humans put a lot of energy into making sure that the pH of our blood is constant,â he went on. âBut some of these lower organisms, they donât have the physiology to do that. Theyâve just got to tolerate whatâs happening outside. And so they get pushed beyond their limits.â
Â
FIFTY MILES OFF THE COAST of Australia and half a world away from Castello Aragonese lies the equally tiny One Tree Island. One Tree, which actually has several hundred trees, is shaped like a boomerang, with two arms that stretch out into the Coral Sea. In the crook of the boomerang thereâs a small research station run by the University of Sydney. As it happened, just as I arrived one spectacular summer afternoon, an enormous loggerhead turtle heaved herself up onto the beach in front of the lab buildings. The islandâs entire human populationâ11 people, not including
Tracie Peterson, Judith Pella