found that the growth of Porites corals, which form massive, boulderlike clumps, declined 14 percent on the Great Barrier Reef between 1990 and 2005.
Â
OCEAN ACIDIFICATION seems to affect coralsâ ability to produce new colonies as well. Corals can, in effect, clone themselves, and an entire colony is likely to be made up of genetically identical polyps. But once a year, in summer, many species of coral also engage in âmass spawning,â a kind of synchronized group sex. Each polyp produces a beadlike pink sac that contains both eggs and sperm. On the night of the spawning all the polyps release their sacs into the water. So many sacs are bobbing around that the waves seem to be covered in a veil of mauve.
Selina Ward, a researcher at the University of Queensland, has been studying coral reproduction on Heron Island, about ten miles west of One Tree, for the past 16 years. I met up with her just a few hours before the annual spawning event. She was keeping tabs on a dozen tanks of gravid corals, like an obstetrician making the rounds of a maternity ward. As soon as the corals released their pink sacs, she was planning to scoop them up and subject them to different levels of acidification. Her results so far suggest that lower pH leads to declines in fertilization, in larval development, and also in settlementâthe stage at which the coral larvae drop out of the water column, attach themselves to something solid, and start producing new colonies. âAnd if any of those steps doesnât work, youâre not going to get replacement corals coming into your system,â Ward said.
The reefs that corals maintain are crucial to an incredible diversity of organisms. Somewhere between one and nine million marine species live on or around coral reefs. These include not just the fancifully colored fish and enormous turtles that people visit reefs to see, but also sea squirts and shrimps, anemones and clams, sea cucumbers and wormsâthe list goes on and on. The nooks and crevices on a reef provide homes for many species, which in turn provide resources for many others.
Once a reef can no longer grow fast enough to keep up with erosion, this community will crumble. âCoral reefs will lose their ecological functionality,â Jack Silverman, a member of Caldeiraâs team at One Tree, told me. âThey wonât be able to maintain their framework. And if you donât have a building, where are the tenants going to live?â That moment could come by 2050. Under the business-as-usual emissions scenario, CO 2 concentrations in the atmosphere will be roughly double what they were in preindustrial times. Many experiments suggest that coral reefs will then start to disintegrate.
âUnder business as usual, by mid-century things are looking rather grim,â Caldeira said. He paused for a moment. âI mean, theyâre looking grim already.â
Â
CORALS, OF COURSE , are just one kind of calcifier. There are thousands of others. Crustaceans like barnacles are calcifiers, and so are echinoderms like sea stars and sea urchins and mollusks like clams and oysters. Coralline algaeâminute organisms that produce what looks like a coating of pink or lilac paintâare also calcifiers. Their calcium carbonate secretions help cement coral reefs together, but theyâre also found elsewhereâon sea grass at Castello Aragonese, for instance. It was their absence from the grass near the volcanic vents that made it look so green.
The seas are filled with one-celled calcifying plants called coccolithophores, whose seasonal blooms turn thousands of square miles of ocean a milky hue. Many species of planktonic foraminiferaâalso one-celledâare calcifiers; their dead shells drift down to the ocean floor in whatâs been described as a never ending rain. Calcifiers are so plentiful theyâve changed the Earthâs geology. Englandâs White Cliffs of Dover, for