From across the circle, Sammie watched me check out Ms. Carewâs fashionable feet and flashed me an amused smile, as if to say, â
I told you she was cool
.â
âToday, Iâd like to ask if anyone is willing to share a secret,â Ms. Carew said. âKnow that whatever we say in this room stays in this room, and that your secret is safe with us.â
The first one to raise a hand was Bernard.
âI keep my weight a secret,â he said, âbecause I weigh more than anyone thinks I do. I have this roll of fat around my middle that no one knows about. When I go to the beach, I keep my shirt on and when my family asks why, I tell them that I donât want to get sunburned. So I guess you could say that everything between my chest and my hips is a big fat secret.â
I was amazed. First, because he was so willing to just put it out there. And second, because I never thought boys worried about their weight or how they looked in a bathing suit. It was news to me.
âI know exactly how you feel, Bernard,â Sammie was saying. âI worry all the time about my weight. Iâm always wondering if everyone is looking at me and thinking how fat I am.â
âYouâre not fat,â I responded immediately. âYou look fine. Dadâs just made you feel fat because youâre heavier than me.â
Ms. Carew held up her hand.
âCharlie,â she said gently. âI know Sammie appreciates your remarks, but weâre not here to talk people out of how theyâre feeling. Whatever they feel is their truth, and we have to listen with open hearts and accept their feelings as real.â
That seemed crazy to me. I mean, just because you feel something doesnât make it true. But everyone else was nodding in agreement. Suddenly, I felt so stupid sitting there.
The next person to talk was Will Lee.
âMy secret is that I like older women,â he said. âIâm only in the sixth grade, but Iâm always falling in love with seventh-graders.â
Was he looking at me out of the corner of his eye? Oh no, I hoped not.
âRecently, I had a crush on one of my sisterâs friends, and sheâs in the eighth grade,â he went on. âI asked if she wanted to hang out with me some weekend, and she rejected me. Made up some phony excuse about having a boyfriend, which I happen to know she doesnât because I hear her talking on the phone with my sister.â
âYou need to pick on people your own size.â I chuckled, giving him a friendly little poke in the ribs. It was hard to take him seriously. He seemed like such a little kid.
âIâm uncomfortable with the way youâre acting,â a girl named Keisha said. I looked around to see who she was talking toâit was me!
âI was just making a joke,â I said.
âWill was opening up about a secret he has,â Keisha said. âI donât think he was looking to be laughed at.â
I felt myself flush with anger.
âI wasnât laughing
at
him,â I said in a voice that sounded snappier than I had intended. âI was laughing
with
him. Thereâs a big difference.â
âCharlie is new to our group,â Ms. Carew told the others. âSheâs just learning to listen and accept.â
Boy, that made me feel even more idiotic. How hard is it to listen? I have ears and Dr. Hartley checks my hearing every year at my annual checkup. I
was
listening. I truly didnât understand what I was doing wrong.
âI just want to support Charlie and say that Iâm glad sheâs here,â Alicia said. âSheâs been going through some tough times, and she could use all our support.â
Everyone in the circle turned to me. I felt like they were expecting me to spill my guts about what Iâd been going through, but I could feel myself closing up like a clam shell. I hate it when Iâm expected to do something that Iâm