donât.
But I have to, I remind myself strictly. Itâs the first step toward being the new me. The wild me.
Iâve walked by Potstill a hundred times and never gone in. In the rich and varied landscape of Brooklyn bars and, more specifically, South Brooklyn bars, Potstill is ⦠well, itâs a dump.
Itâs dirty, for a start, with dusty smeared windows and cracked windowsills, and not in a charming Wild West kind of way, just in a forgotten kind of way. I donât think itâs changed since the early â80s, at least. Most places around Gowanus have been hipsterfied by now, but Potstill is stillâalmost refreshinglyâa total dive.
The front part of Potstill is very narrow, opening up to a weird cavernous space at the back where Madeleineâs band is setting up. Thereâs a bottle-crammed bar along one wall, and the whole thing is lit by harsh fluorescent bulbs, making everyone look sallow and dull. The walls are green and entirely bare apart from a handful of askew photos of the bar in its heyday thrown up haphazardly in cheap rusted frames.
We walk into the bar and pause, taking it all in.
âWhat a dump,â comments Angie.
âMaddy, shouldnât you go help the band set up?â says Julia.
âI canâtâ¦â Suddenly, Madeleine can hardly speak. âIâm so nervous. All I can do is drink coffee, but I think I overdid it. Look.â Madeleine holds up a visibly shaking hand. âUgh. I feel sick.â
âEat some salty potato chips,â says Julia. âSodium works to counteract the caffeine, and the carbs release serotonin to calm your adrenals. They have some in the bodega on the corner.â
âIs that true?â asks Pia, as Madeleine runs off to the bodega to find potato chips.
âI made it up,â says Julia. âI figure itâs probably all in her head, right? So if she thinks sheâs calmer, sheâll be calmer ⦠anyway, fuck, potato chips wonât kill her. Sheâs too goddamn skinny.â
Madeleineâs band is called Spector. It does hard rock covers of girl group classics from the 1960s, you know, stuff from the Supremes and the Ronettes. Maddy was with another band, but after she stepped in to help out Spector at a gig a few months ago, they recruited her, and that was that. Kind of funny how sheâs an accountant by day and a singer by night, huh? Itâs like sheâs leading a double life.
âI feel so much better,â says Madeleine when she returns, stuffing chips in her mouth. âMaybe that was just nerves. The owner of this place, Gary, also has two bars in Williamsburg. If he likes us, we could get a regular gig with him. But I bet no one even turns up ⦠Amy is going to be pissed. â
Amy is the guitar player and unofficial leader of the band, a tall girl with pink hair and black-red lipstick who scares the crap out of me. Sheâs been over to Rookhaven a few times to rehearse with Madeleine.
âMad! Thank God! I need you!â calls Amy, and Madeleine skips back to where Amy is setting up with Hoff, a stoner/guitar player that was in Maddyâs old band too, and Drum, their imaginatively nicknamed drummer.
âWhere the hell is the bartender?â says Angie, sitting down on a rickety barstool. âAnd how shitty is this joint?â
âVery,â says Julia, taking a seat next to her and pulling a mismatched stool over for me. âShitty McShitterson.â
Looking around, I frown. I donât think itâs that shitty. The actual bar itself, you know, where the drinks are mixed, is kind of cool. Very old but beautiful wood, with cracked varnish worn down from years of drinking. Itâs the crappy green walls and the falling-down plasterboard ceiling thatâs the real problem. Itâs just a bit dirty, and not cozy or welcoming. And itâs too hot and the lighting is just way too bright and white to flatter