The Republican Brain

Read The Republican Brain for Free Online

Book: Read The Republican Brain for Free Online
Authors: is Mooney
that it had only recently become possible to be.
    His contemporaries described him in paradoxes: the “rabid sheep,” the “volcano covered with snow.” In person, he was shy and inarticulate, as well as sickly and unhealthy. Yet he could explode with passion when inspired by ideas.
    As he ascended in Enlightenment circles, Condorcet got to know luminaries like Voltaire, Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Jefferson, and Tom Paine. But he embarked on an intellectual quest perhaps more ambitious than any of theirs, seeking nothing less than to derive a “science of society.” Condorcet’s motto was “social mathematics,” and his creed probability. We can’t know much with certainty, he reasoned, but for many things we can at least know their likelihood—a fact with vast political implications.
    Applying such principles would make government more enlightened, scientific.
    As the revolutionary period neared—and the political distinctions of “left” and “right” were first defined, based upon whether or not one wanted to overthrow France’s ancien regime —Condorcet got to test his ideas. He was elected to the newly formed Legislative Assembly in 1791 and became its president. He was also elected to the 1792 Convention, the new republic’s first governing body, and served as its vice president.
    Yet in this maelstrom, reason did not prevail—and neither did Condorcet. He wasn’t a very good politician; certainly, he was no straight-arrow decider like George W. Bush.
    Instead he was a man of too much nuance at a time of too strong passions, and before long he fell on the wrong side. Condorcet’s allies, the moderate Girondists, were thrust out of the convention on June 2, 1793. Condorcet had played a central role in drawing up a constitution for the new republic, based on his probabilistic principles. But it was tainted with the perception of Girondism, and the Convention ultimately rammed through an alternative, Jacobin constitution instead.
    And here was Condorcet’s fatal mistake—he couldn’t keep silent. He had to stand up for reason and argue back. So he circulated an anonymous pamphlet blasting this constitution, but his identity was exposed and the Jacobins called for his arrest. He escaped, went into hiding, and started writing his greatest work, the Sketch for a Historical Picture of the Progress of the Human Mind .
    Condorcet would have been laboring over it as his Girondin friends were guillotined, and when he himself was condemned to death for conspiring against the Republic. The Sketch’s greatness thus derives not solely from its contents, but also from its unique character as an unfolding nonfiction tragedy. It’s the literary equivalent, wrote the famed anthropologist James George Frazer, of a “great fresco on a prison wall.”
    After reading Condorcet, you can never think about “reason” in the same way again.

    Condorcet’s Sketch is the most powerful work of nonfiction I’ve read. In 2009 while a visiting associate at Princeton University, I was first introduced to photocopied excerpts of the work—but that just wasn’t enough.
    So I paid nearly $100 on Amazon for my own copy. I can’t think of a book that moves me more; but then, I’m a liberal who cares about science and ensuring a more enlightened society. I would love it, wouldn’t I?
    But Condorcet’s vision doesn’t just stir me—it saddens me deeply. Reading Condorcet is like dousing liberal-scientific assumptions about human rationality in what Ted Koppel once called an “acid bath of truth.”

    Condorcet began at the dawn of humanity with “man” in a “state of nature.” He then showed how humanity had proceeded to elevate itself to an apotheosis of reason that has no boundary, save the “absolute perfection of the human race.” The “perfectibility of man is

Similar Books

Being Human

Patricia Lynne

Obsession

Karen Robards

My Share of the Task

General Stanley McChrystal

Deadly Beloved

Jane Haddam

What the Moon Saw

Laura Resau

Come Sit By Me

Thomas Hoobler