true but it didnât bother either of them.
âMaybe I should.â He unloaded his plate of meat loaf and put both their empty trays on a nearby waiter stand. Coming back to the table but still standing, he said, âWell?â
âIâve been through every legal hearing in which the agencyâs been involved in remit transgressions, particularly under Nixon and Bush. As well as through all the textbook references I could locate. I couldnât find anything that even came close to this. And hacking isnât a crime, by our definition; that is what our remit is, entering other peopleâs communications without their knowledge or permission, although Iâve never considered myself working as part of a botnet.â
Singleton began to eat. âI couldnât find a definite legal bar, either. But itâs pretty well set out that NSA doesnât perform field operations.â
âJack covered that very specifically. Any fieldwork or humint retrieval is carried out by the CIA. And since 9/11 the courts have returned ambiguous rulings against us when weâve been accused of wiretapping and bugging here at home, despite Signals Intelligence Directive 18 specifically prohibiting it without a warrant from the Foreign Intelligence Surveillances Court.â
âWashington commandment handed down from Mount Sinai: âNothingâs wrong or illegal until youâre caught doing it,ââ recited Singleton, quoting the in-house cynicism. âDonât forget the 2013 uproar over our Prism Project precisely to monitor Facebook through Britainâs GCHQ, for which we gratefully handed over something like one hundred and fifty million dollars. What happens if thereâs another whistle-blower like Edward Snowden?â
âThereâll be another uproar,â accepted Marian drily, working her way through her salad.
âCan we belatedly object?â
âNo,â she said without hesitation.
Singleton pushed his plate away, the meat loaf half-eaten. âAccording to our contract terms, we could simply withdraw. We didnât know what we were doing during the initial period.â
âYou mind taking that meat loaf away?â said Marian, a vegetarian. âIt smells disgusting.â
âTasted disgusting, too.â Singleton transferred the plate to the waiter stand. âI asked what youâre going to do.â
Marian didnât reply at once, chasing the last crouton around her dish. âIâm not sure where Iâm safer, inside from where Iâll be able to assess the dangers and accusations before theyâre made. Or outside, to plead ignorance when it all goes wrong.â
âIâm not sure a court would accept an ignorance plea. Or that ignorance is even a defence.â
âWeâre staying in, arenât we?â accepted the woman, resigned.
âI guess.â
âBut Iâll keep looking for something that gives it some legal justification.â
âSo will I,â said Singleton. âLetâs hope it doesnât have to come from our trial lawyers.â
*Â Â Â *Â Â Â *
James Bradley prided himself on covering all the bases, which he wasnât able to do with Jack Irvine, and it unsettled him. His difficulty was in having to rely on records and written accounts of Irvineâs cryptographic brilliance, unsupported by any biographical material apart from the abbreviated account of the debacle surrounding Irvineâs ambassador father, which, realistically, he might have misinterpreted and didnât have any relevance anyway.
There were, of course, the obvious practical precautions such as the CIA surveillance heâd imposed upon Irvine and his Fort Meade team. Bradley looked up from the list of CIA internal-security officers he was forming to watch over Irvine and the operation, halted by a sudden doubt about Harry Packerâs reliability. Shouldnât Packer be
Nick Stephenson, Kay Hadashi