and loaded them with goods and produce to
sell for high dollar in New Orleans. When the Red
River rose enough for safe passage, usually in the
spring, they would begin their journey up the Red
River to the Cumberland, then to the Ohio and
Mississippi rivers, landing in New Orleans some
weeks later. After selling their goods, they would sell
the scrap lumber from their flatboats for extra money
to return home on.
The first marriages in the Bell family took place in
1817 when daughter Esther and son Jesse married
their neighborhood sweethearts, Alex Porter and
Martha Gunn, respectively.
Because of their acts of kindness, fair business
dealings, and strong religious convictions, the Bells
became a family of great prominence and enjoyed a
good rapport with other families in the community.
John Bell was a man of great wealth and influence in
the community, eventually becoming an elder of Red
River Baptist Church, an honor that he and his
family held in the highest regards. 14 The Bell home
was the site of many social gatherings where the
Johnstons, Gunns, Forts, Frank Miles, and others
frequently gathered for dinner, chat and worship.
One of the most frequent visitors to the Bell home
was Professor Richard Powell. A man of knowledge
13 Tennessee Grant Book K , p. 403.
14 Red River Baptist Church Minutes (1791-1826) .
THE BELL WITCH: THE FULL ACCOUNT
35
and polite manner, Powell always made it a point to
visit the Bells when he was in the area. He always
began his visits by praising Elizabeth’s progress in
school, and often spoke of her irresistible charm and
beauty.
Another frequent visitor to the Bell home was
Joshua Gardner, a handsome and well-mannered
young man who lived on a farm that bordered the
south side of the Bell property. It seemed the only
thing Gardner and Professor Powell shared in
common was their unmistakable fondness for
Elizabeth Bell.
Joshua Gardner, six years Elizabeth’s senior, was
known as one of the brightest and most outspoken
young men in the community, and never once
attempted to hide his fondness for her. The Bells
were very fond of Gardner and his family, and had no
problems with his visiting Elizabeth on a regular
basis. At the young age of 12, Elizabeth was not yet
ready for serious courtship and spent much of her
time with other girls.
Elizabeth’s two closest friends were Rebecca Porter
and Partheny (Theny) Thorn. Rebecca Porter was the
younger sister of Alex Porter, who married Elizabeth’s
older sister, Esther. Theny Thorn was the adopted
daughter of James and Jane Johnston. The three
girls were the best of friends, and often slumbered,
went on picnics, and took hikes together through the
forest and along the Red River.
36 P A T
F I T Z H U G H
CHAPTER THREE
Trouble Begins
A LARGE AND HAPPY FAMILY, the Bells
enjoyed everything life had to offer — until
one day in 1817. What happened on that
cool, fall day would remain with John Bell’s family
for the next eleven years, inflicting terror and
humiliation that would alter their lives forever and
baffle the most learned of scholars.
Strange Animals and People Appear
John Bell was walking through one of his
cornfields when he came upon a strange-looking
animal standing in a corn row. Its body was
unmistakably that of a dog, but the head closely
resembled that of a rabbit and had bright, green
eyes. Unlike anything Bell had ever seen before, the
creature stared at him for several minutes without
moving.
Baffled and somewhat frightened, Bell loaded his
shotgun and took aim at the creature. As quickly as
THE BELL WITCH: THE FULL ACCOUNT
37
he could put his finger on the trigger, the creature
ran away. He looked through every corn row for the
creature but found nothing, not even a track.
Although he could not easily forget the sinister look
that the creature gave him, Bell decided it was
probably a mix-bred dog that had strayed into the
cornfield.
Bell
Jessica Conant-Park, Susan Conant