next door, and maybe heâd have one after work, seeing it was so convenient for him to do so. That was how easily it started. You had to be on your guard. As soon as somebody balled up a handkerchief, left it lying on the end table, thereâd suddenly be a couple of pennies, a pen, a scrap of paper beside it.
âRosie,â Bethany had told her sister, âyouâve got yourself and those kids to think of. Donât let Ma go bullying you if you donât want her living with you.â
âI just think you ought to take a turn for a while,â Rose said. âJust give me a break from her, thatâs all.â
But that kind of thinking was the beginning of the end. It was the beginning of Ma and those dresses she couldnât be botheredto wash, and that stinking little dog sheâd adopted last year and doted on more than she ever did on Bethany. It was the beginning of forgetting where you drew the line. For by the time you were in a particular situation, that line got hard to see because there were people stepping all over it, waving their arms, hollering and crying and making demands. The thing was to keep yourself clear of those troubles. The thing was to understand your limits, to put your foot down with a boom. Bethany had known before sheâd married Fred that he had his familyâs taste for booze. But she also knew he had a kind heart and a yearning for better things, and sheâd designed the house to feed those inclinations.
After supper, Fred led everybody into the living room to play cards around the coffee table as Bethany put the leftovers away, did the dishes and wiped down the cupboards and washed the floor. By then it was nearly eleven, time to leave for Midnight Massâif you didnât get there early, youâd end up standing at the back. Bethany had taken the boys each year since they were old enough to sit up in a pew. Religion, like a spoonful of cod-liver oil, was an easy ounce of prevention, even though some might protest its bitter taste. She stuck her head in the living room. The Christmas tree cast a warm light over the crèche in the big bay window, and Bethany admired the faces of the shepherds, the wise men, the little drummer boy. Even the animalsâ dull expressions were made human in the presence of the Baby Jesus. Mouths parted expectantly. Eyes solemn with hope. Sheâd draped the top of the crèche with red ribbon that matched the ribbons on the gifts beneath the tree, and these matched the tiny red bows she had glued to each of the golden ornaments. The angel sheâd seated at the treeâs tippy top, a white bulb illuminating her dress, looked down upon everything with pleasureâexcept for the bottle of Wild Turkey, the men hunched over their cards. Pete and Robert John sat beside them; Gabriel dozed on the love seat, hismouth open on one of her nice throw pillows, his coat tugged carelessly over him.
âPete, Robert John,â she said. âTime to get ready for church.â
The men had cigars tucked in their shirt pockets; Bethany saw Pete had one too. And perhaps it was that cigar which made him decide to feel his oats a little. âOh, Ma,â he said. âIâm too old for that sort of thing.â
âMe too,â Robert John said.
âThen I guess youâre too old for what Santa brought you,â Bethany said.
Pete sighed theatrically; Robert John popped to his feet. In the fall, Fred had taken the boys out to look at snowmobiles, and they suspected, rightly, there was something waiting for them in the milk house under a tarp. But then Fred said, âAw, Beth, donât you think Peteâs old enough to make up his own mind?â
And before Bethany could reply, Pete said, âDadâs right. Iâm not a kid anymore.â
Dad . Sheâd been after the boys to call Fred that since they were married, but this was the first time either one had done so. Fred beamed, knuckled