you for possessor of a functioning tongue.
LUDWIG: There’s that we again, I’ll thank you not to speak for us.
CLARISSA: And I’ll thank you ( to Ludwig ) not to speak for us; perhaps we want him to speak for us.
NESTOR: Thank you.
CLARISSA: But we don’t, I don’t, don’t speak for me.
LUDWIG: For me either.
NESTOR: So you guys thought Chuck, uh Charles, could speak…
LUDWIG: No.
CLARISSA: Not in a million years.
NESTOR: yet somehow chose to not utter a solitary syllable in the many months…
CLARISSA: Years.
LUDWIG: Decades.
NESTOR: . . . he’s been here?
LUDWIG: He’s an enigma.
CLARISSA: Enigmatic. A mystery.
LUDWIG: Mysterious. A riddle.
CLARISSA: Ridiculous, subject to ridicule.
CHARLES: I’m right here, I can hear you, and it hasn’t been that long.
NESTOR: Wait, what do you mean by that?
CHARLES: I haven’t been here that long, that meaning.
NESTOR: So how long?
CHARLES: Feels like I just got here really.
( Nestor looks at the others as if vindicated. They won’t meet his eyes except Adam who fails to see the relevance.)
CLARISSA: You say feels like but you also recognize that you’ve been here a while, longer than any of us, right?
NESTOR: No, I’ve been here the longest.
CLARISSA: What are you talking about? I was here when you arrived. I remember it like it was yesterday.
LUDWIG: It was yesterday!
CLARISSA: That’s right, it was. You just got here and already with the bossing everyone around.
NESTOR: I remember when Charlie arrived and it was a long time ago.
LUDWIG: Years.
CLARISSA: Eons.
NESTOR: Chuck has always been here and always will.
CHARLES: I’m leaving soon.
LUDWIG: No he’s never been here and never will.
CHARLES: I’m right here.
CLARISSA: Charles has never been where he’s going and only gone where he’s been.
( Everyone ponders that a while. )
ADAM: But where?
LUDWIG: Who said that?
CLARISSA: The new guy.
NESTOR: New guy my ass, he’s been here longer than any of us, even longer than Charles and Charles has never not been here.
CHARLES: He sure as Shinola was here when I arrived.
ADAM: Where when you arrived?
CHARLES: What?
LUDWIG: Who invited this guy?
ADAM: ( to Charles ) When you arrived where?
CHARLES: Here! What’ve we been talking about? ( looking to the others for support ) Believe this?
ADAM: But where is here?
LUDWIG: Right here. ( gesturing ) See? ( all laugh )
ADAM: But what is this? Where are we?
( Laughter stops abruptly and the ensuing silence is extended and palpably meaningful .)
NESTOR: ( to Ludwig ) You were saying?
LUDWIG: I wasn’t.
NESTOR: What?
LUDWIG: Saying.
NESTOR: What’d you say?
LUDWIG: I didn’t say anything. You were saying you were saying and I was saying I wasn’t saying. ( Pointing to Clarissa ) She was saying ( pause ) just saying.
NESTOR: Fine ( to Clarissa ) you were?
CLARISSA: Saying? I was saying that when we say, say, what was I saying?
NESTOR: Exactly.
LUDWIG: Well that’s settled then, off we go.
( No one moves. )
CHARLES: Besides it’s not where we are it’s what we are and the answer is brains in a vat.
NESTOR: We debunked that already, weren’t you listening?
CHARLES: Listening as we debunked brains in a vat? No, missed that.
CLARISSA: Debunked is too strong, as I recall much spoke in its favor.
LUDWIG: Much indeed, great intuitive appeal.
CHARLES: Which one was brains in a vat again?
CLARISSA: Which one? How about the one you just declared the truth.
CHARLES: I know, and I remember being persuaded, just not very strong on the particulars right now, refresh please.
NESTOR: Brains in a vat, the thesis that we, the inhabitants of this room, are merely…
CLARISSA: Certainly