him.â
âScott?â
âYes.â
âAnd you feared he might try to harm her?â
I shrugged. âIt occurred to me.â
âDo you know for a fact that she didnât bring a knife with her?â
âNo,â I said. âI guess I donât. I stayed in bed.â
âAnd you went back to sleep.â
âYes.â
âSo you have no idea what she did between the time she left the bedroom and when you heard her screaming.â
âI have a very good idea,â I said. âShe told me.â
âBut she could be lying.â
I sighed. âSheâs not lying.â
âIn fact,â he said, âif youâre telling the truth, you really cannot tell us anything about Ms. Banyonâs actions this morning between the time she walked out of your bedroom and when you heard her screaming and came upon her with Scottâs body in the driveway, is that right?â
âI am telling the truth,â I said.
I wondered what they were asking Evie. Probably establishing the fact that she couldnât account for my actions while she had been jogging in Brewster.
They had themselves two excellent suspects.
Vanderweigh led me through his questions again, and then Lipton came over and sat with us and asked me the same damn questions. I asked for more coffee, and Vanderweigh went and
got it. Iâd had no breakfast, and I was feeling woozy and lightheaded. The coffee helped a little.
It seemed like Iâd been in there for several hours when there came a soft knock on the door. Lipton got up and went out of the room.
He was back a minute later. He was holding a plastic zippered bag. He put it on the table between us. It held a knife. The blade was five or six inches long with a serrated edge. It looked like a steak knife.
âRecognize this, Mr. Coyne?â said Lipton.
âNo. Is it the murder weapon?â
âMaybe.â He glanced at Vanderweigh, then turned back to me. âIt appears to match a set of knives from the kitchen in the cottage you were renting.â
I said nothing.
âIt was found in the bushes about twenty feet from Larry Scottâs body.â
âSo itâs probably the murder weapon,â I said.
âThat remains to be seen,â said Vanderweigh. âTake another look at it.â
I looked at it and shrugged. âWeâve only been in the cottage since night before last. We havenât cooked or eaten there, except for cereal yesterday morning and sandwiches for lunch. We didnât use any sharp knives. The woman who owns the place kept the key under the doormat. Anybody couldâve gotten in there.â
They asked me a few more questionsâthe same ones theyâd been asking me beforeâand then the two of them looked at each other, and Vanderweigh said, âTerminating interrogation atââ He glanced at the clock on the wall. ââat eleven forty-seven A.M.â He snapped off the tape recorder. âYouâre free to go, Mr. Coyne, but Iâve got to ask you not to return to that cottage.â
âCrime scene and all.â
âYes.â
âFor how long?â
âA couple days, anyway.â
âSo whatâre we supposed to do?â
âThatâs up to you. Go home, if you want.â
âAll our stuff is in that cottage. My carâs there.â
Vanderweigh nodded. âIâll have one of the Brewster officers take you back to get your things. Iâm afraid you canât have your car for a while, though.â
âYou think we killed him somewhere else and transported his body to our driveway?â I said. âSo we could find it and report it and make ourselves logical suspects?â
He shrugged. âWhy donât you go clean out the cottage? When you get back, Iâm sure someoneâll be happy to help you find a rental.â
âWhat about Evie?â
âYou can wait here for