if Mission Control picked Langhorne and Bédard because the planners knew they were megalomaniacs?
He tried to tell himself that that was only because of the weariness almost sixty standard yearsâalmost sixty-five local yearsâof watching the two of them in operation had made inevitable. Unfortunately, he couldnât quite shake the thought that the people whoâd selected Eric Langhorne as the colonyâs chief administrator and Dr. Adorée Bédard as its chief psychologist had known exactly what they were doing. After all, the survival of the human raceâat any costâwas far more important than any minor abridgments of basic human rights.
ââand we implore you, once again,â the slender, silver-haired woman standing in the center of the breezy hearing room said, âto consider how vital it is that as the human culture on this planet grows and matures, it remembers the Gbaba. That it understands why we came here, why we renounced advanced technology.â
Kau-yung regarded her with stony brown eyes. She didnât even look in his direction, and he felt one or two of the Councillors glancing at him with what they fondly imagined was hidden sympathy. Or, in some cases, concealed amusement.
âWeâve heard all of these arguments before, Dr. Pei,â Eric Langhorne said. âWe understand the point youâre raising. But Iâm afraid that nothing youâve said is likely to change our established policy.â
âAdministrator,â Pei Shan-wei said, âyour âestablished policyâ overlooks the fact that mankind has always been a toolmaker and a problem solver. Eventually, those qualities are going to surface here on Safehold. When they do, without an institutional memory of what happened to the Federation, our descendants arenât going to know about the dangers waiting for them out there.â
âThat particular concern is based on a faulty understanding of the societal matrix weâre creating here, Dr. Pei,â Adorée Bédard said. âI assure you, with the safeguards weâve put in place, the inhabitants of Safehold will be safely insulated against the sort of technological advancement which might attract the Gbabaâs attention. Unless, of courseââthe psychiatristâs eyes narrowedââthereâs some outside stimulus to violate the parameters of our matrix.â
âI donât doubt that you canâthat you have alreadyâcreated an anti-technology mind-set on an individual and a societal level,â Shan-wei replied. Her own voice was level, but it didnât take someone with Bédardâs psychological training to hear the distaste and personal antipathy under its surface. âI simply believe that whatever you can accomplish right now, whatever curbs and safeguards you can impose at this moment, five hundred years from now, or a thousand, thereâs going to come a moment when those safeguards fail.â
âThey wonât,â Bédard said flatly. Then she made herself sit back a bit from the table and smile. âI realize psychology isnât your field, Doctor. And I also realize one of your doctorates is in history. Because it is, youâre quite rightly aware of the frenetic pace at which technology has advanced in the modern era. Certainly, on the basis of humanityâs history on Old Earth, especially during the last five or six centuries, it would appear the âinnovation bugâ is hardwired into the human psyche. It isnât, however. There are examples from our own history of lengthy, very static periods. In particular, I draw your attention to the thousands of years of the Egyptian empire, during which significant innovation basically didnât happen. What weâve done here, on Safehold, is to re-create that same basic mind-set, and weâve also installed certainâ¦institutional and physical checks to maintain that