That guilt that settled on me in that motel room in Birmingham becomes heavier. Did Merry Carole want to go with me all those years ago? No. She loves North Star. Why donât I? With my single-minded kitchen life in all those cities, I didnât have time to ask these inconvenient questions. Finally. Something positive that came out of all those years. Merry Carole speaks quickly. âI donât mean to make you feel bad. I just . . .â
âNo, youâre right.â
âIâm glad youâre back.â
âMe, too.â
We are quiet.
âBut youâre thinking about the next city already, right?â Merry Carole asks, her voice clear, her eyes focused.
âYes, maâam.â
âIs North Star that bad?â
âFor me? Yes.â
âThatâs just ridiculous.â
âAre you trying to tell me theyâve gotten better?â I say, motioning to the world just outside Merry Caroleâs sanctuary of a home.
âAre you trying to tell me that whatever life you had in New York or Los Angeles or whatever that place was with all the turquoiseââ
âTaos.â
âTaos? Are you saying that Taos is worth what it took out of you?â Merry Carole motions at me and the shadow Iâve become.
âSo you admit that theyâre still just as shitty.â
âSo you admit that all those cities were just shitty.â
We are quiet.
âCalâs just like you. All he wants to do is leave,â Merry Carole says, not looking at me.
âI know.â
We fall silent again.
âIf youâre looking for something to do, you can go visit Mom,â Merry Carole says.
âPlease donât tell me youâve been going there.â
Merry Carole says nothing.
âI donât know what you think youâre going to find. Itâs not like she can apologize or make amends,â I say, sipping my coffee.
âItâs called forgiveness, Queen Elizabeth. Itâs the Christian thing to do.â
âWell, seeing as how sheâs dead and buried, I imagine it makes it a lot easier to forgive her.â The last time I was in North Star I was feeling particularly dramatic and drove over to the cemetery thatâs just off the church in the center of town. I got out of my car and immediately crumpled into tearsâthe kind of tears that feel so vast itâs alarming and mystifying at the same time. Then, just as quickly, I swept all those emotions aside and decided never to return. I do that a lot.
âDonât talk like that.â
âYou donât talk like that.â
âMe? Me donât talk like that?â
âDonât you dare try and make a hero out of that woman. I swear to God,â I say, leaning on the dining room table.
âIâm not making a hero out of her, for heavenâs sake. Iâm just saying that while youâre back in town for the twenty minutes you plan on staying, you might want to drive by the cemetery and place a nice bouquet on her grave.â
A moment passes.
âYou ever think about her?â I ask.
The room goes cold. Merry Carole circles the rim of her coffee mug with her manicured fingers. Her face is twitching with all the energy itâs taking to remain neutral.
âSometimes,â Merry Carole says, finally looking up to meet my gaze.
âI check on her, you know,â I say.
âYou what?â
âYou can check on the prison Web site, you know . . . how sheâs doing, if she won all those appeals.â
âShe murdered two people in cold blood and got the death penaltyâthose appeals are offensive.â
âShe murdered her own husband and the woman he was cheating on her with in her very own bed. A woman who was her very best friend right up until she cocked that shotgun,â I say, taking a sip of my coffee. My hands are shaking.
âYvonne Chapman is a monster and thatâs all Iâm