the books. Perhaps they feel similarly about their friends, parents, children. âThe trouble with my kid is that she doesnât make me care enough about her.â Are we all supposed to nod sagely at that?)
It is not intended to be a backhanded compliment when I say that TóibÃn doesnât care whether you care about Eilis, his heroine; itâs not that the book is chilly or neutral, or that TóibÃn is a disengaged writer. Heâs not. But heâs patient, and nerveless, and unsentimental, and he trusts the story rather than the prose to deliver the emotional payoff. And it does deliver. Brooklyn chooses the narrative form of a much cheaper kind of bookââone woman, two countries, two menââbut that isnât what itâs about; youâre not quite sure what itâs about until the last few pages, and then you can see how carefully the trap has been laid for you. I loved it. Will I wreck it? Itâs perfectly possible, of course. Itâs a very delicate piece, and Eilis is a watchful, still center. I wonât have to hack away at its complicated architecture, though, because it doesnât have one, so maybe I have half a chance. By the time you read this, I should have started in on it; if you have a ten-year-old daughter with ambitions to be an actor, then she might as well start trying to acquire an Irish accent. In my experienceof the film business, weâll be shooting sometime in 2020, if it hasnât all collapsed by then.
In a way, I read Live From New York , an oral history of Saturday Night Live , because of work, too. Earlier in the year I got an American agent, a lovely, smart woman whose every idea, suggestion, and request Iâve ignored, more or less since the moment we agreed sheâd represent me. Anyway, she recommended Tom Shales and James Andrew Millerâs book, and my feeling was that if Iâm not going to make her a penny, I could at least follow up on her book tips. And Iâm pretty sure that if it had to be one or the other, money or successful recommendations, sheâd go for the recommendations. Thatâs what makes her special.
I read the book despite never having seen a single minute of Saturday Night Live , at least prior to Tina Feyâs turn as Sarah Palin in 2008. The show was never shown in the U.K., so I hadnât a clue who any of these people were. Will Ferrell? Bill Murray? Adam Sandler? Eddie Murphy? John Belushi? Chris Rock? Dan Aykroyd? Itâs sweet that you have your own TV stars over there. Youâve probably never heard of Pat Phoenix, either.
When itâs done well, as it is here, then the oral history is pretty unbeatable as a nonfiction formâengrossing, light on its feet, the constant switching of voices a guarantee against dullness. Legs McNeilâs Please Kill Me: The Uncensored Oral History of Punk , George Plimptonâs Edie Sedgwick book, Studs Terkelâs Working ⦠These are books that I hope to return to one day, when Iâve read everything else. Live From New York is probably just a little too long for someone unfamiliar with the show, but if you want to learn something about the crafts of writing and performing, then youâll pick something up every few pages. I am still thinking about these words from Lorne Michaels:
The amount of things that have to come together for something to be good is just staggering. And the fact that thereâs anything good atall is just amazing. When youâre young, you assume that just knowing the difference between good and bad is enough: âIâll just do good work, because I prefer it to bad work.â
Michaelsâs observation contains a terrible truth: you think, at a certain point in your life, that your impeccable taste will save you. As life goes on, you realize itâs a bit more complicated than that.
While I was reading Live From New York , I realized that G. E. Smith, the showâs musical