that Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld took a hard look at the team Feith and Garner had assembled. The next day, Rumsfeld summoned Garner. According to Garnerâs account of the discussion, Rumsfeld began with an apology.
âJay, I havenât paid enough attention to you,â he said. âI should have given you more of my time.â
Then he proceeded to question the credentials of several top ORHA staffers, particularly those from the State Department. âHe said, âIâm just uncomfortable with these people,ââ Garner recalled. âI said, âUh, itâs too late for you to be uncomfortable with them. Iâm leaving tomorrow.ââ
âHe said, âIâll get you new people.ââ
âI said, âYou donât have time to get me new people.ââ
After more back-and-forth, Rumsfeld asked Garner to look over his staff list and indicate who âyou absolutely have to keep.â
âAnd I said, âBy the way, who would DOD have thatâs qualified to do agriculture?â And he didnât say anything, so I said, âHow about education?â And I went down [the list] and I said, âHow about banking? Who could do banking?â So he said, âLook, I donât want to argue with you on this one, but Iâm gonna get you better people.ââ
As soon as Garner left, Rumsfeld blocked the departure of senior State Department personnel assigned to ORHA on the grounds that they were âtoo low-profile and bureaucratic.â He relented only after Powell called and threatened to pull every State employee from ORHA, which undoubtedly would have been front-page news. The Pentagon wanted as few State people on the team as possible, but not at the price of a public-relations embarrassment.
When Garnerâs advance team arrived in Kuwait in early March, they were informed that there was no room for ORHA at any of the military bases in the city-state. They would have to find their own accommodations. The only place with enough beds was a Hilton beach resort, which set aside a wing of luxury villas for Garner and 168 other ORHA members, who arrived in Kuwait the day before the war began. The group spent almost six weeks consuming gourmet meals and sipping sparkling water as they worked up plans to deliver food rations and drinking water to Iraqi civilians. The Hiltonâs two-story, cream-colored villas had down pillows, flat-screen televisions, maidsâ quarters, and breezy balconies overlooking the Persian Gulf.
Meetings consumed much of the mornings, but most were rambling affairs lacking specificity. Because everyone assumed that Iraq would be in the throes of a humanitarian crisis after the war, several sessions were devoted to planning the distribution of food and water. Garner also convened ârock drills,â military-speak for simulation exercises. One drill assumed that corpses would be littering the streets of Baghdad, electricity would be out, and parts of the city would be on fire. Some ORHA members regarded the scenarios as far-fetched, but they nonetheless talked about how they would respond. They knew they didnât have enough staff or equipment, but they figured they would have military units at their disposal to provide transportation, communication, and other much-needed assistance.
It wasnât that Garner didnât have a plan. The one he had was titled âA Unified Mission Plan for Post Hostilities Iraq.â It was marked SECRET/REL USA MCFI , meaning it could be shared only among Americans with appropriate security clearances and vetted members of governments who had joined Bushâs âcoalition of the willing.â By the time Garner arrived in Kuwait, the second draft of the document had grown to twenty-five pages. It began with a one-page introduction written by Garner. The first sentence was both prescient and banal: âHistory will judge the war against Iraq not