said.
âWithin the next forty-eight hours is our window,â Herb explained.
âAnd I bet you have a plan you are ready to talk to us about,â the judge said.
I knew he was right. Herb was always playing chessâtrying to stay a few moves aheadânot just with the enemy but with the people sitting around this table. Heâd been thinking about this plan from the instant that bridge went down.
âThe captain and I can present a comprehensive plan to this committee within an hour.â He looked from person to person. âWell?â
âIâm not sure I should even be in on the discussion,â Mr. Peterson said. âIâm a farmer, and thatâs all I am. I donât know about attacks and what needs to be done in situations like this.â
âMe neither,â Mr. Nicholas added. âAs an engineer, I find all this well beyond my area of expertise. Canât we just leave this up to the captain and Herb, Howie, and the judge to decide?â
There was a nodding of heads and agreement from most of the others who werenât included in that group of names.
âNo,â my mother said, silencing them. âWe canât. These decisions affect everybody, and we all have to have input.â
âSheâs right,â Herb agreed.
That surprised me. I thought Herb would have welcomed the opportunity to do things that way, without consultation or interference from more people.
âIn an ideal world every member of this community would contribute to the decision because it will have dire, potentially fatal, impacts on them. We donât live in that ideal place, but all of you are the neighborhoodâs representatives. This has to be a collective decision because we will all have to live with the consequences. If we attack it is almost guaranteed that some of our people will die. We have to share in that responsibility,â Herb said.
There was silence in the room as his words sank in. I think most of them would have relished washing their hands of the decision and then not being held responsible for what would happenâafraid of the consequences. Now theyâd have to live with them, good or bad, successful or tragic.
âI just wish we could give them the opportunity to lay down their weapons,â Judge Roberts said.
âTheyâd never do that,â Herb said.
âHow can you be certain?â Howie asked.
âThe problem with a liar is that he doesnât believe anybody else is capable of telling the truth,â Herb explained. âTheyâd think it was just a trick and that as soon as they surrendered their weapons weâd cut them down.â
âWe wouldnât do that,â Judge Roberts said.
âBut they would , and thatâs how they think everybody thinks. Theyâre not going to simply walk away,â Herb said.
âBut if they did, would we let them?â I asked.
He didnât answer right away. He looked like he was struggling to come up with the right words. âIt wouldnât be my decision to make.â
âBut if it was?â I wasnât going to let him get away without giving an answer.
He took a deep breath. âThose people have done evil and will be prepared to do evil again. If we let them walk away, then weâre responsible for every action they take from that point on. Every death done by them would have been allowed by us. So, in answer to your question, I donât think they will surrender, but even if they did they shouldnât be allowed to leave ⦠or live.â
âAnd you think we should just kill them all?â my mother asked.
He looked straight at my mother. âYes.â
âBut if we did, doesnât that just make us the same as them, putting a bullet into the head of an unarmed man?â Judge Roberts asked.
âItâs not the same. Theyâre prepared to kill innocents. Iâm proposing that we kill the guilty to