you got into the bus yesterday noon?â
The spokesman, thus perilously addressed, said with haste: âNo, sir, I did not. Iâm really sorryââYou see, we didnât thinkâI canât understandâââ
âAll right, all right,â said the Inspector in a gentler tone. âIâm not going to bite you. Iâm just looking for information. Iâll tell you what I want to know. You people say there are seventeen in your party. You were seventeen when you left Bohunkus, or wherever you come from; you were seventeen when you landed in New York; you were seventeen when you checked into this dump; youâve been seventeen on your jaunts around the city. Right so far?â
There was a unanimous nodding of heads, executed with rapidity.
âThat is,â continued Thumm thoughtfully, âup to noon yesterday. Youâd chartered a bus to take you around. You went over to the Forty-Fourth Street and Broadway terminal of the Rivoli company, and you got into your bus. Were you seventeen on the way to the terminal?â
âIâI donât know,â said the spokesman helplessly. âI really donât.â
âAll right, then. But one thing is sure. When that bus started out there were nineteen people in it. How do you account for that?â
âNineteen!â exclaimed a stout middle-aged lady with pince-nez glasses. âWell, I noticedââI wondered what that man was doing there!â
âWhat man?â snapped the Inspector; and Patience dropped the spoon she had been toying with and sat very still, watching the mingled triumph and perplexity on the stout ladyâs face.
âWhat man, Miss Ruddy?â echoed the spokesman, frowning.
âWhy, the man in that outlandish blue hat! Didnât any of you notice him? Martha, I believe I mentioned him to you before the bus started. Donât you remember?â
The bony virgin named Martha gasped: âYes, thatâs right!â
Patience and the Inspector looked at each other. It was true, then. George Fisherâs story had been based on verifiable facts.
âDo you recall, MissâerâRuddy,â asked Patience with a winning smile âother details of this manâs appearance?â
Miss Ruddy beamed. âIndeed I do! He was middle-aged, and he had an enormous moustache. Just like Chester Conklinâs, in the movies.â She blushed. âThe comedian, you know. Except that it was grey.â
âAnd when LaviniaâMiss Ruddy pointed him out to me,â added the raw-boned lady named Martha excitedly, âI saw that he was tall and thin, too!â
âAnybody else notice him?â demanded the Inspector.
There were blank looks.
âAnd didnât it occur to you ladies,â continued Thumm sarcastically, âthat a man you didnât know had no right being in your privately chartered bus?â
âOh, it did,â faltered Miss Ruddy, âbut I didnât know what to do. I thought he might have had something to do with the bus company, you see.â
The Inspector rolled his eyes ceilingward. âDid you notice this bird on the return trip?â
âNo,â said Miss Ruddy in a trembling voice. âNo, I looked especially. But he wasnât with us.â
âFine. Now weâre getting somewhere. But,â said the Inspector with a grim smile, âthat only makes eighteen. And we know there were nineteen of you yesterday in that bus. Come on now, folks, think hard. Iâm sure somebody here must have noticed the nineteenth person.â
âI believe,â murmured Patience, âthat that charming lady at the end of the table remembers something. Iâve seen a speech trembling on her lips for the past two minutes.â
The charming lady gulped. âIâI was only going to say,â she quavered, âthat I did notice somebody else whoâwho didnât belong. Not the man in