wavers and straightens itself so quickly that I wonder if I imagined the change. But then sheâs walking back toward the couch. When she sits down, Iâm relieved.
âMy brother Clive thinks Iâm dog crazy,â she says.
âIn this office,â I respond, deadpan, âwe call it âdog normal.â â
Anyaâs lip twitches. Is that the beginning of a smile? I sense something shifting between us. The line was a joke, but I was also serious. Itâs important that my patients know they arenât alone in caring deeply for an animal companion. Our dogs see us at our best and at our worst, and love us with unparalleled devotion through it all. We share our lives with them. They know ourdeepest, darkest secrets, things that sometimes our closest human confidants donât even know. No one should feel ashamed for caring for another being, for feeling heartbroken when a friend is gone. What is more ânormalâ than love?
I add Cliveâs name to my notebook and ask Anya if people have responded to the flyer.
âYeah,â she says, âbut nothing pans out. Henry thinks the reward is too highâitâs pulling liars out of the woodwork.â
âWhy do you think your brother suggested you see me?â
Anya rolls her eyes. âSuggested? Forced . He said if I didnât come talk to you heâd tell my grandmother that heâs worried about meâabout my mental health . My grandmother is old and sick and the last thing she needs is to get worked up over me. Anyway, I think Henry just feels guilty. Heâs moving to Los Angeles next month and heâs trying to tie up all the loose ends before he leaves. If he makes me come see you he can tell himself that he tried to help me.â
I jot down a note about her grandmother, and another about her brother moving away. âAre you close with Henry?â I ask.
She shrugs. âI guess.â
âWhy do you think heâs concerned about you?â
Anya begins biting the nail of her pointer finger, which is when I notice that all of her nails are bitten down to the quick. Some are bloody, others just ragged.
I ask her if sheâs having trouble sleeping and her eyes shoot to mine.
âWould you be sleeping if your dog went missing?â she asks. âIf you just came home from work one day and he wasnât there?â
That explains the dark circles. I donât blame her; sleep hasnât comeeasily to me lately either. When I finally drift off in the early hours of the morning, I always hope Iâll see Toby in my dreams. I never do, waking only with an empty feeling, his absence highlighted.
From the look of Anyaâs scarecrow limbs and the hollows below her cheekbones, Iâm guessing she isnât eating much either.
Instead of answering, I ask, âIs that what happened? You came home and Billy was gone?â
âYeah, but he didnât run away. He would never do that. I walk him without a leash all the time and he never goes more than a few steps away from me.â She starts playing with her coat zipper again.
âIf he didnât run away, what do you think happened to him?â
âSomeone stole him.â She juts out her chin, challenging me to argue.
âThatâs terrible! Did someone break in? Was there . . . was anything else taken?â
âNo, no.â She looks away, her shoulders slumping. She takes a deep breath, and when she speaks again she sounds exhausted. âI know what youâre thinking. Who would steal an old mutt? Believe me, my brothers have all been sure to tell me how nuts I sound. But nothing else makes sense. Billy wouldnât run away, so someone must have stolen him. Heâs somewhere in the city and Iâm going to find him.â She tells me that sheâs been walking through the city, looking for her dog, every morning of the last twenty-four days.
I canât help but agree with her brothers;