Kirkâs not what she needs? Heâs a good man, a hard worker.â
âJust because you like him doesnât mean she should marry him. Thereâs no spark there or they wouldâve married long ago. They act more like buddies than lovers.â
But Kirk had been around for so many years, heâd already found his place in the family and was unlikely to disturb the delicate equilibrium of relationships. âShe needs to do something. Sheâs thirty-six years old.â
Allie chuckled. âSo are you. Thatâs hardly ancient.â
âSheâs still talking about having a large family.â
âSheâll find the right man.â
âKirkâs the right man,â he insisted. âShe should marry him, have a family and forget the past.â His mood darkened as he folded his arms. âInstead, sheâs spending good money on a P.I.âa P.I. who could ruin her life.â
âGuilt, responsibility and curiosity are all powerful motivators,â Allie said. âYou, of all people, should understand that.â
âWeâre not talking about me,â he grumbled.
Her smile was back. âIf you only knew what a good man you are.â
He shoved the hair out of his eyes. It was getting long; he could use a cut. âItâs enough for me that you think Iâm good.â
âMaybe if Maddy still had her mother, the situation would be different,â she said.
âOf course it would. Then my mother wouldnât have married Lee Barker. He had nothing nice to say about his first wife, but you know he never wouldâve divorced her. That wouldnât have reflected well on him.â He heard the bitter note in his own voice. âHe was all about appearances.â
She bent over to kiss his cheek. âYouâve done your best with what you were given, done your best by Maddy. You love her just as much as your other sisters.â
âBut itâs probably not the same for her,â he said. âShe belongs, and yet sheâs the only one who doesnât really belong. Thatâs got to be hard.â
âNot as hard as it could be if she ever finds out the truth.â Allie walked over to get the phone. âSo call her.â
âAnd say what? Hey, Maddy, take it from meâyou donât want to know what you think you want to know?â
She tugged playfully on his hair. â No. Tell her the case is too old, that this P.I. wonât uncover anything new, that itâll cost her a lot of money for nothing. And if that doesnât work, just let her know you donât approve.â
âI canât come on too strong,â he said.
âWhy not?â
âBecause itâs a miracle folks around here havenât poisoned her against me.â
âSheâd never turn on you.â
âShe could if this P.I. comes to town.â
âWhich is why you have to convince her not to bring him here,â she pointed out.
âI doubt that anything I say will change her mind.â
âItâs worth a try,â Allie insisted and handed him the phone.
Â
The phone in Madelineâs office had been ringing all morning. It seemed as if everyone in Stillwater had something to say about the discovery at the quarry, which came as no surprise to her. People in this town had been talking about her fatherâs disappearance for years, and the knowledge that his car had been found renewed public interest.
Fortunately, most were well-intentioned calls, friends and acquaintances who, after hearing the latest, wanted to give Madeline a kind word or a little encouragement. But there were a few who used this latest development to try to undermine her faith in the Montgomerys.
Madeline would rather have skipped every one of those calls in favor of some peace and quiet. It was difficult enough writing about her father without so many interruptions. But she was anxious to hear from Chief Pontiff, to