his hand back up on the table. He tapped the next arrow and read, âF, fuh, F.â He hit advance. âS, sss, S.â His eyes flicked up to see how this sudden success was being received.
âGood,â Asimov 3000 said. âAgain.â
The boy got the next one and the one after that. So his mistakes had been willful. It reminded Asimov 3000 of MasterVandleyâs children. Then, he would sit at the head of the table with the children to either side of himâexcept on the days Master Vandley took charge of the childrenâs lessons himself, of courseâand sometimes the children would answer every question wrong for spite. But to get every question wrong, you had to know the right answers so as not to stumble upon them by accident.
Beachstone scratched his thigh again, but Asimov 3000 refrained from comment. He had not been distracted by his studentâs sudden improvement as the boy hoped, but if whatever Beachstone was hiding was important, it would come out. âLetâs try some reading,â he said. He took the tablet and navigated to the easy-reader section, then placed the tablet on the table in front of the boy.
â âThe c-aaa-t,â â Beachstone sounded out, â âis ff-aaa-t.â â He took a deep breath, sat up straighter, and resumed. â âThe c-at is saaad.â â
âGood.â
â âThe cat is aaa-lll-ss-oooââ Alsoo?â Beachstone tapped the word, and the voice said, âAlso.â â âAlso.â Damn it.â
âDonât give up so easily.â
âI should have known that.â
âBeachstone,â Asimov 3000 said, and paused. The boy kept his eyes down. âYouâre learning. Try again.â
â âAlso cr-cr-yuh.â â He reached to touch the screen, but Asimov 3000âs hand darted out, blocking him.
âTryââ
Beachstone slid both hands under his teacherâs, pressing the whole screen. The recordings for the rest of the words on the page all played at once over each other in a jumble of sound.
Asimov 3000 said nothing. They sat in silence for a moment, Beachstone with his head down.
âWhy do I have to learn this stuff anyway?â Beachstone said.
âWhy would you not want to learn to read?â Asimov 3000 said.
âEverything can read itself out loud. Or a robot can just do it for me.â
âWhat if you need to read a sign? Or the power is out?â
âThe power doesnât go out,â Beachstone said.
âThe power has not gone out in thirty-two point six four years, but it can happen.â
Beachstone reached out and tapped the tablet. The womanâs voice intoned, âCrying.â
âThis is a waste of time,â Beachstone said. âIâm never going to need to read.â
Asimov 3000 tried to think of a response. The boyâs discouragement hurt. With Master Vandleyâs children, there was never any question as to what purpose learning to read served. Master Vandley presented it as an absolute fact. But Asimov 3000 had to admit that it had been seventy-three years since heâd last had a child pupil, and perhaps things had changed. âTry again,â he said.
Beachstone didnât move.
Asimov 3000 considered. âThere was a time when humans could trust robots, as you are suggesting, rely on them. But now, if you donât know how to read, you will never know who you can believe.â
Beachstoneâs face pulled tight.
âYou canât trust anyone anymore, Beachstone.â
âWhat about you?â the boy said.
âMe, of course,â Asimov 3000 said, âand your brother and sisterââ
Beachstone flinched.
âMary and Kent,â Asimov 3000 corrected. âBut you may not always wish to stay at Barren Cove.â Master Vandleyâs children hadnât.
âI wish I could just upload reading into my brain like a