sheâd never said anything. âI was embarrassed about being there by myself. Itâs not something I usually do.â
âIâm glad you were there,â he said as he headed to the refrigerator for the sauce. âExcept for your little episode with the jerk, itâs great to see you. So are you back in Thunder Canyon to stay?â
She sighed and sounded so forlorn that Tootsie must have sensed it. She nuzzled her leg. âI donât know. Every thingâs inâ¦limbo. My mother wanted to come home for the holidays and begged me to come with her so I took a temporary leave from my job until the new year. After that, I donât know what Iâll do.â
He really hoped she would decide to stay. He likedhaving her around. He started to say so but she spoke before he could get the words out.
âI guess you heard about myâ¦about what happened twenty-six years ago.â
âWho in town hasnât?â
Her sigh this time sounded even more forlorn and he cursed himself for his tactless response.
âSorry. Was that the wrong thing to say?â
âI really hate having everyone gossiping about me. I hated it after my dadâs murder and I hate it more now. Everything is such a mess.â
He couldnât begin to imagine what she must be going through. âHow are you holding up?â
âNot too great,â she confessed softly.
He set down the box of pasta heâd just pulled from the cupboard and crossed to give her a reassuring squeeze on the shoulder.
Instead of comforting her, as heâd intended, his gesture made her big blue eyes brim with tears.
âMy mom wants the family together for Christmas. Everyone, including Erin.â
âAnd thatâs a problem?â
She sighed. âI feel like I donât even belong at Cliftonâs Pride anymore.â
He stared. âYou most certainly do belong at Cliftonâs Pride! Itâs your home and the Cliftons are your family. Why would you feel otherwise, even for a moment?â
âIâm not a Clifton. Not really. If not for a quirk of fate and a momentâs mistake by a nurse, I never would have known any one of them. Iâm not a Clifton. But Iâmnot really a Castro, either. I barely know those people. I donât know who I am.â
A tear brimming in her eyes dripped over and slid down the side of her nose and his heart broke.
He grabbed a tissue box and couldnât resist the compulsion to pull her into his arms. She felt small and feminine and he wanted to hold tight and take on all her demons for her.
âYouâre the same person youâve always been. Youâre Elise Clifton, daughter of John and Helen and sister to Grant. Blood or not, thatâs who you are.â
âI wish it were that easy.â
âWhy isnât it? Theyâre your family.â
She frowned. âTheyâre not my parents! I donât belong in Thunder Canyon at all!â
A dozen arguments swarmed through his headâhe hadnât been in law school without reason. But then, she wasnât a hostile witness on the stand, either.
âSo blood and genetics is everything? According to your reasoning, anybody whoâs been adopted into a family should always feel like an outsider.â
âI wasnât adopted!â she exclaimed. âI was switched for their real daughter. For the child Helen and John should have had. They didnât choose to be stuck with me. My whole life is a mistake! Iâm a mistake.â
âDo you really think thatâs what your mother and Grant think?â
âI donât know. Theyâre so happy about Erin,â she whispered.
Her tears started flowing in earnest now and she added a few sobs in there to really twist the knife.
Nice, Cates, he thought. Take a vulnerable woman who has already had a rough night and reduce her to tears. He had definitely lost his touch.
âHey. Easy now. Come