had begun building the Long Island Expressway, Mumford launched a spirited attack on the projectâand on Mosesâin the pages of The New Yorker . Mosesâ New York, Mumford thought, had âbecome steadily more frustrating and unsatisfactory to raise children in, and more difficult to escape from for a holiday in the country.â By now, both men were diametrically opposed in their core beliefs. While Moses famously claimed that âcities are created by and for traffic,â Mumford firmly believed and repeatedly stated that highways do not mitigate traffic; they create it. âA city exists, not for the constant passage of motorcars, but for the care and culture of men,â said Mumford, who in 1961 published his award-winning book, The City in History.
Not that Moses cared. He lumped Mumford in with the academic critics âwho build nothing.â In the meantime, Moses continued to accumulate positionsâand powerâlike trophies; La Guardiaâs successor, Mayor William OâDwyer, added Construction Coordinator and Chairman of the Emergency Committee on Housing to his growing portfolio. By the 1950s it was impossible to build anything in New York without Mosesâ consent. If he opposed a projectâas he did when Brooklyn Dodgers owner Walter OâMalley wanted to build a new ballpark in Brooklynâit never happened; if he wanted a project realizedâa baseball stadium in his favored Flushing Meadow Park in Queensâit was built.
But for all his power and influence,Title I almost proved Mosesâ undoing. Each time he embarked on the construction of new housing, streets and neighborhoods had to be condemned, and the unfortunate souls who called those neighborhoods home had their lives upended. Over the course of his Title I reign, Moses uprooted tens of thousands of New Yorkers, old and young alike, replacing neighborhoods with concrete-slab towers. âThere is nothing wrong with these buildings,â Mumford wrote after taking a tour of a few newly created housing projects, âexcept that, humanly speaking, they stink.â
In 1959 a scandal revealed that notorious mob boss Frank Costello, button man Vinny âthe Chinâ Gigante, and other assorted mafiosi were involved in one of Mosesâ Title I public housing programs. While Moses didnât know of the mob connection, the incident stained his reputation and, most infuriating, allowed his media critics an opportunity to publicly tar and feather him. Costello Pal Got Title 1 Deal, roared the New York Post ; Banker Had Warning on Costello Pal, clamored the New York World-Telegram.
Moses was incensed. Mayor Wagner and Governor Rockefeller were under pressure to do something with the aging Master Builder, to strip him of some of his titles at least, which wouldnât be easy, as Wagner could testify. In 1954, right after taking the oath of office, Wagner swore in Moses as City Parks Commissioner and City Construction Coordinator. When he was done, Moses stood at attention waiting for Wagner to swear him in as Chairman of the City Planning Commission.
After all the other administration appointees took their oaths, the mayor still hadnât done so. Moses followed Wagner into his private office. What the Master Builder didnât know was that Wagnerâs aides had been pressuring the mayor not to allow Moses to head the Planning Commission. Holding all three positions would give Moses the power to propose and green-light public works projects with little to no oversightâfar too much power in one manâs hands.
Behind closed doors, Moses informed Wagner that if he wasnât reappointed the head of the Planning Commission, he would resign his other posts, immediately. Wagner froze. He said it was just a clerical oversight; give it a few days, he promised, and the situation would all be sorted out. Moses walked out, grabbed a blank application form from a nearby office, filled it out,