said. âInteresting. But donât we have an obligation to figure out the truth?â
âNot if lies make more sense,â Francesca answered cheerfully
She did it again !!!
âThatâs just stupid,â Brendan snorted.
âI agree,â Nisha said. âWho cares if a lie makes sense. Itâs just wrong.â
Espee bowed her head. âFair enough. But letâs avoid words like âstupidâ and âwrong.ââ
âEven if you totally disagree with someone?â Nisha argued. She glanced quickly at Lily, who glanced quickly
at me.
âListen, guys, this is really important,â Espee said firmly. âIn this class, thereâs never just one answer, like in math. There are only
interpretations,
supported by
evidence.
So what about yours?â
I realized she was pressing on my shoulder with a cool, dry hand.
âMine?â I said.
âYes, you. Our note taker.â
âHer name is Evie,â Francesca announced. âEvie Webber.â
Nisha kicked me
âThanks, Francesca,â Espee said. She looked at me as if she was expecting something important.
And then I panicked, because Iâd totally lost track of this discussion. I stared blindly at the quote on the whiteboard:
History is a story we tell ourselves.
âUm. Well. I think lies always get found out, even if they
look
like they make sense. I mean, at first. But maybe . . .â
âYes?â
âI donât think thatâs what the quote means. Itâs about stories. And stories are different from lies.â
âHow so?â Espee asked, speed-walking away from me. âAre stories true?â
âThey donât have to be. But they could be
based
on the truth. They make more sense if they are. In the long run. And, anyway, no one
means
them to be false, so itâs like theyâre bigger than lies.â
Kayla made a face. âI have no idea what youâre talking about, Evie.â
âNeither do I,â I admitted. A couple of kids behind me laughed.
But then I said, âMaybe stories just have more sides to them. So theyâre more complicated than lies. And also more interesting.â
âHmm. Very thoughtful, Evie,â Espee said. Her eyes sparkled at me from across the room, and I realized Iwas blushing. âWell, weâll have to keep thinking about the difference between stories and lies, and why we tell ourselves U.S. history in the first place.â
She reached her strong-skinny arm into a leather briefcase and took out some papers. Then she sat on top of her desk and crossed her legs like she was doing yoga.
âAll right, then,â she said, in a campfire sort of voice. âIf history is a story, whatever that means, this year letâs agree to tell ourselves the best, most fascinating story we can. So weâll be doing very little textbook work. Thatâs the good news.â
âWhatâs the bad?â asked Brendan
Espee smiled. She started passing around the papers
Nisha looked at me and murmured, âOmigod, Evie. Sheâs giving work
already
?â
I didnât answer. I just took a paper and read
SP USH ATTIC PROJECT
Step 1: Go up to your attic. (Interpret âatticâ loosely.)
Step 2: Find some family document(s) relating to a particular event or period in U.S. historyâe.g., a scrapbook, a diary, some correspondence. Almost anything goes, as long as itâs written
Step 3: Analyze closely, using multiple outside sources. (Take lots of notes. Try to fill a whole spiral notebook!
Step 4: Find out all you can about the author. What sort of storyteller is/was he/she?
âDonât have an âatticâ? See me for a Mystery Box.
âWork in pairs; either personâs âatticâ is fine
âStart now. Make daily progress. Finish by September 18
chapter 4
Twelve days?â
Nisha screeched as we left the building. âSheâs giving us twelve
R.L. Stine - (ebook by Undead)