hair was longer and there was an air of girlish awkwardness about her, but her features were clearly recognizable.
âYou will forgive me for pointing out that not all wives are great beauties,â said Carmichael.
âOh, yes, they are,â she contradicted him. âNo man has ever married a woman he didnât think was beautiful. He may be aware that she doesnât look like Elizabeth Taylor, it may be purely an inner beauty, recognizable only to himself. But he always thinks sheâs beautiful in some way, and I never had any inner beauty, either. The other girl in the picture,â she added, âwas my sister, Gwenda.â
Carmichael turned his attention back to the photograph, interested to see Berowneâs first wife. She looked tiny beside Miss Wellman. She, too, was dark-haired, but otherwise there was not the slightest resemblance. This girl was round-faced, with a sweet smile and large, gentle, dark eyes.
âShe looked like our mother,â said Miss Wellman. âI took after Fatherâin more ways than looks.â
âYou were very fond of her?â asked Carmichael.
âOh, yes. Everyone was.â Miss Wellman looked up, staring into the fire. âShe was one of those rare creatures. She had the true gift of happiness and everyone she came into contact with gleaned a little of it. She was a very gentle person, but she could always smooth things over. She liked doing it, it was easy for her.â She sighed and turned back to her knitting. âIt would have been much better if I could have died instead of her. Then Geoffrey would still be alive, and still happily marriedâbecause their marriage was a happy one, odd as that always seemed to me. And he would certainly have been on better terms with Paul.â
âYou think Gwenda would have smoothed out their business differences?â
She hesitated for a moment. âOh, yes,â she said, a trifle too casually. âShe was good at things like that.â
So, thought Carmichael, they had differences outside of business, too. But all he said was, âHow long ago did your sister die?â
âNearly eight years ago now. I came to live here a few years before that, when my arthritis started acting up and I had to give up teaching. I wasnât too sure about it really, but Gwenda was quite firm that I should come and, actually, it worked out very well. When she died, Geoffrey made a point of asking me to stay on, so I did. Weâd gotten used to each other by then, you see. It wasnât the same without Gwenda, but we got on all right.â
âUntil he remarried?â suggested Carmichael gently, but she was not to be drawn out. She gave him an amused glance.
âIt didnât make a great deal of difference to me,â she said. âBeyond that I didnât like to see Geoffrey making a fool of himself and that I had to put up with Annette at mealtimes. Geoffrey always insisted on family meals.â
âSo you didnât resent Mrs. Berowne?â
âDonât be silly, Chief Inspector. Of course I resented her. Any fool could see that. I probably would have resented any woman who tried to take my sisterâs place. I also might have got over that if she hadnât been such a conniving little twit. Annette has never thought of anybody but herself in her whole life.â
Carmichael frowned at this; Annette had not struck him as a conniver, and he wondered if her undeniable charm had affected his judgment.
âDid you feel that she treated Mr. Berowne badly?â
âIt depends on what you mean by that,â she replied, giving him a wry glance. âShe kept up the illusion she was in love with him, billed and cooed over him and all that, but thatâs about all she did. Kitty and I still run the house between us.â
âSo you feel she didnât take on the responsibilities she should
have?â Carmichael tried to keep his tone neutral, but