wholesomely informative. Let me read it to you. âSix murders have been committed during the first nine months of this year and the six murderers are still at large. Scotland Yard detectives were concerned in four of these cases.ââ
âSounds as if we committed them,â interrupted the inspector testily.
ââNine murders took place last year and are marked in the police records as âundiscovered,âââ continued Vereker relentlessly. ââScotland Yard inquired into seven of those crimes. A plain fact must be statedâScotland Yard, the most highly organized police department in the world, has lost the habit of catching murderers.ââ
âCatching murderers is an art, not a habit, Mr. Vereker, with all due respect to the Daily Express correspondent.â
âPerhaps youâre right, inspector. But what are you going to do about it?â
âCatch âem in future if we can. In the art of criminal investigation, just as in your jobâif you can call it a jobâof painting, thereâs a power of luck. Only you can burn your duds while ours are put on record for critical Press correspondents to chuckle over,â replied the inspector, with a show of warmth.
âNeatly expressed, inspector, but only partially true. The critical Press correspondents generally manage to chuckle even over our successes. We have that disadvantage. But letâs get to the Armadale case. Youâve been over the ground and got the general hang of things. I know only what Iâve gathered from the newsâfragmentary, uncertain, inconclusive stuffâpoor foundations to build on. Of course it was a murder and not suicide.â
âOh!â said the inspector, looking up with his slow, inquisitive glance. âHow did you tumble to that?âÂ
âJust a guess,â replied Vereker lazily, âan idle guess. I donât think a man would commit suicide by shooting himself in the stomach. There were two bullet wounds: one in the head and one in the abdomen, I believe?â
âThatâs true, and the guess is quite a good one, but only a guess. If a manâs determined to do himself in thereâs no saying how heâll do it if his mind is sufficiently worked up. A man has committed suicide by beating his head almost to a pulp with a hammer; another by driving a chisel several times into his skull. At first glance these actual cases looked like particularly brutal murders, and yet they were proved without any doubt to have been suicides.â
âAmazing! What do you think about it yourself, Heather?â
âLike you, Iâve guessed itâs murder. But itâs too early in the day to say much more. For instance, suppose Mr. Armadale wished it to be thought that he had been murdered. There have been hidden reasons for such a trick on several previous occasions. It might be done to avoid trouble over insurance money; to incriminate some innocent person in a mad spirit of revenge.â
âQuite so, but thereâs something fishy about those two woundsâone in the abdomen, the other in the right temple. It was in the right temple, wasnât it?â
âThatâs correct, and Mr. Armadale was gripping his Colt .45 automatic pistol in his left hand. Whatâs the bright amateur deduction from that, Mr. Vereker?â asked the inspector, with his heavy, good-natured face breaking into a smile.
âI thought that would be the first, dull, official question, inspector. I guess it puzzled you immensely. I thrashed it out with myself this morning while I was hunting for my back collar-stud. As youâve got a flying start of me, I must ask you a few questions. In the first place, was Mr. Suttonâs left thumb on the trigger?â
âNo, there was neither digit nor thumb within the trigger guard.â
âDigit is luscious, inspector! You ought to be on the Daily Report . Weâll