Read The Dinosaur Feather for Free Online Page B

of light appeared in the darkness.
    If
Tybjerg was right,
if
it really was the case that the kinship of birds to dinosaurs was as well-supported as Tybjerg and Helland and . . . she did a quick count . . . around twenty-five other vertebratists from all over the world agreed it was, then it had to follow that their scientific position was the stronger, at least for now, as Dr Tybjerg maintained, and if that were true, well, then it was indeed remarkable that reputable journals such as
Nature, Science
and, in particular,
Science Today
, which owed their existence to their scientific credibility, continued to waste column inches on it. Anna still remained to be convinced that this was the case, but that seemed secondary now. The situation would have been different if a sliver of doubt remained.
If
birds might have been dinosaurs,
if
fossilised evidence had yet to be discovered, which Anna could see had been the case in the 1970s and 1980s,
if
the feathered
Sinosauropteryx
hadn’t been found in 2000 or the feathered
Tyrannosaurus
in 2005. But there was plenty of fossil evidence. The feathered dinosaur was a reality, and it was clear in every single paper which argued in favour of the close kinship between birds and dinosaurs that the authors were convinced that birds were dinosaurs.
Utterly
convinced.
    Anna stared into space.
    Dr Tybjerg had told her that the editorial committee of a scientific journal typically consisted of five people with a science background, which broadly speaking meant that fifteen people from the three leading journals,
Nature, Science
and
Science Today
, were in supreme command of which scientific topics would reach the public. Fifteen people. That’s not many, Anna thought, and in order to avoid giving preferential treatment to certain subjects or areas of research, those fifteen people had to consider very carefully if what they published did, in fact, reflect the actual work being carried out across the world. And this was where things didn’t add up. Even though experts agreed that birds were present-day dinosaurs, Anna found in every other journal, at least, new contributions to the debate. She could feel the excitement pump through her body. Quick as lightning she sorted the papers into two piles, then she highlighted the names of the authors in yellow, and when that was done, she leaned back and smiled. There were twenty-four full-length papers and minor contributions in the pile which supported the kinship of birds to dinosaurs; there were twenty-three contributions in the pile which didn’t believe that birds were present-day dinosaurs. Together, Dr Tybjerg and Professor Helland accounted for five of the articles in the one pile; the remaining nineteen had been written by sixteen other vertebratists from universities all over the world. It was a rather convincing spread.
    Then she went through the pile with twenty-three papers. These were written by three different authors. Clive Freeman, Michael Kramer and Xian Chien Lu. Clive Freeman and Michael Kramer were responsible for nineteen out of the twenty-three articles. Anna got up and found a computer with Internet access. First she looked up Xian Chien Lu and discovered that the Chinese palaeontologist had died the previous year. That left only Clive Freeman and Michael Kramer. It took Anna eight clicks to learn that Michael Kramerhad completed his MSc at the Department of Bird Evolution, Palaeobiology and Systematics at the University of British Columbia in March 1993, been awarded a PhD grant in 1993 by the same department and written his thesis there from 1997–2000, after which he had been employed as a junior professor in June 2000. Anna’s eyes scanned his CV and soon found what she was looking for: his MSc and his PhD supervisor was Professor Clive Freeman, his internal PhD examiner was Professor Clive Freeman, and the Senior Professor at the Department of Bird Evolution, Palaeobiology and Systematics was Clive Freeman. For the first