explained: a guy was missing, the police knew he had gone to Twitchellâs garage, and he had already admitted in the interview that the missing manâs licence plate and keys were in his own car. On top of that, here he was with a ludicrous story that he had bought the missing manâs vehicle for only forty dollars with no bill of sale from a mystery man with a Celtic knot tattoo. Twitchell had said repeatedly that he bought the car on October 15. But having checked in on the rest of the police team during the break earlier in the night, Clark knew Joss had already revealed how Twitchell had called him to move the car on October 17, while a neighbour had spotted the Mazda parked at the garage on October 14. And Twitchellâs version of events had changed repeatedly. It had changed from the previous nightâs interview, changed from his written statement, and continued to change even while he was talking with Clark. The detective knew Twitchell was lying about the padlock and was suspicious about the barrel. The jerry can in his trunk made no sense either. Who buys a can of gas for a lawn mower they donât own? Nothing was adding up. It was time to fess up.
âYouâve changed your whole story. Told all kinds of different lies.â
As Clark picked off the list of inconsistencies, Twitchell hid his face with his hands and avoided looking at him. He stroked the bridge of his nose with his index finger, sighing repeatedly.
âWhat happened to John, Mark? What did you do to him?â
âIâm done,â Twitchell said. Clenching his first, he pressed his knuckles against his temples. He wanted out. âIâm just not talkinâ anymore.⦠This is ridiculous.â
Clark didnât budge. âWell, what is your explanation? You havenât answered any of the questions! If you didnât do anything wrong, why wouldnât you answer those questions?â
He stopped the interrogation briefly and tried to engage Twitchell as a friend.
âWhat drove you to this? Obviously thereâs something going on behind the scenes that I donât know about. You seem like a decent guy that, hell, Iâd even go have a beer with.â
Twitchell looked up for a second and then furrowed his brow, deep in concentration.
âThatâs the type of guy you come across as being,â Clark added, smiling. âYet, youâre involved over your head in this.â
Twitchell had seen this good cop, bad cop routine before and called Clark out on it: âIs anything that youâre saying genuine or is this some sort of tactic?â
âYou gotta get away from the acting part, Mark, and listen to what Iâm saying.â Clark turned aggressive. âYou have told me
nothing
but lies. An innocent man does not come in here and tell lies. Thatâs
genuine
, Mark.⦠Everything Iâm telling you in here is genuine.â He stopped for a second to let it sink in. âSo get outta your film producer mode and the facade of thinking that everyoneâs an actor.â
Twitchell made a face and adjusted his feet.
âThis is real life, all right? Real life. If you were telling me the truth, you would have one story. One story that would flow from beginning to end.â Clark waved his hand from right to left. âAnd you could repeat that story one hundred times with no changes.â He snapped his fingers. âYours is soooo bad.â
Twitchell remained silent, thinking, before finally responding. âI, I just â¦Â I know weâre not sitting in a movie, but itâs the cop thing.â
âThis is real-life stuff,â Clark said. âYou gotta get away from the movies.â
âYeah, I know.â He sighed.
âThatâs the problem here.â Clark pushed one last time. âYouâre not gonna be able to live with yourself, with this, for the rest of your life.â
Twitchell crossed his legs, tucked his
Lynn Messina - Miss Fellingham's Rebellion