small, maybe five foot three, andâlike Brendaâshe seemed more exotic than the wholesome-looking Dutch girls of Warner Pier. She had dark eyes and a beautiful tan. Her hair was blond, true, but it was the frankly fake kind of blond.
I kept feeling that I ought to know who she was, but I hadnât managed to place her. I decided to try. âJill, are you here just for the summer?â
âYes.â
âYou mentioned that you and Jeremy worked together. Where do you work?â
Jill shot a quick glance at me, then dropped her eyes to the sand. âItâs just a summer job,â she said. âHow long will these guys look for Jeremy before they give up?
âI donât know.â Had she just changed the subject? âThey wonât look for, well, too long. The lake currents make it hard to predict just where . . .â
I stopped. Maybe Iâd said enough. âWhere are you from, Jill?â
âIâm from Indianapolis. Iâm a senior at Northwestern.â
âGreat school! Whatâs your major?â
I got that under-the-lashes look again. âIâm in the School of Communication.â
âIs that journalism?â
âNot exactly.â She looked at me. âYouâre sure thereâs no way to make a cell phone call from here?â
âNo. Thereâs no service on the lakeshore. But I can take you up to my house if you want to make a call.â
âIt doesnât seem right to leave. But I need to talk to my . . .â She hesitated. âOur boss.â
âIâm sure heâs heard what happened by now.â
âI know!â Jill turned around and stared at the people on top of the bank behind us. âI donât understand why he hasnât come.â
The line of volunteers had reached the edge of the water. They dropped their arms and began to talk to one another. Hogan, who was directing the operation, began to gesture to his left, apparently indicating where they would try the next time. Three of the women came over for bottles of water. None of them spoke to Jill, and she didnât look up at them.
Jill and I sat silently until they went back into the water, linking their elbows again and forming a line in a new area. It didnât seem to be a likely spot to me. It was south of the spot where Jill thought Jeremy had gone down. The southwest current should have washed him farther north. But what did I know? Hogan was the expert.
Jill was still drooping. She pulled her knees up to her chest and rested her head on them. It was as if she couldnât stand to look at the water any longer.
I tried to think of something comforting to say. Even though she had denied several times that she had any deep emotional attachment to Jeremy, witnessing something like this had to be upsetting. I was upset, and Iâd never met Jeremy. I knew the morning had been a nightmare to Jill.
What could I say to her? My mind was a blank.
Then I heard a womanâs voice behind me. âJill! Lee!â
I pulled myself out of my own four-inch-high chairâan awkward jobâand crawled out from under the umbrella. Jill stayed where she was, but she lifted her head.
I looked toward the bank behind us. A woman was standing at the top, behind the yellow no-admittance tape. She was waving a big straw hat. âLee! Jill! Itâs me! Maggie.â
I walked toward her, and she waved again. âThey wonât let me through unless you vouch for me!â
It was Maggie McNutt, who had been aboard Joeâs Shepherd Sedan the night we were boarded by the pirates.
Before I could do anything to indicate that Maggie should be allowed on the beach, a streak of white terry cloth went by me.
âMaggie! Maggie!â Jill was running up the stairs toward the top of the bank. âI am so glad youâre here!â
As Jill ran by, I realized where Iâd seen her before, why she had seemed so familiar to me.
Jill was