sit here, and Emma on the other side. John had some business, but will be here soon.â
âYouâre going to let her get away with that?â Natalie whispered.
I shrugged as I took my seat. I didnât really want to give Bennettâs mom one more reason to dislike me. On the other hand ⦠it really bugged me.
âCeleste is dead, Mrs. Stern,â I said, putting my napkin in my lap. âSheâs not deaf.â
âPardon me?â
âYou donât need to compel her to do things. You can just
ask
.â
âIâm sure Celeste doesnât mind, Emma,â she said, a little flustered.
âCeleste wouldnât mind if you used her as a footstool. That doesnât make it okay.â
She gazed at me for a long moment, and I wished Iâd kept my mouth shut. She was that scary. But Mr. Stern stepped into the room before she could respond. He was wearing a navy button-down tucked into khaki pants and a frown, and he looked almost surprised to see us there.
âGirls,â he said briefly, before settling at the head of the table.
Natalie and I eyed Mrs. Stern warily, but she apparently decided to let my little outburst go.
And thus began the Christmas Eve from hell. Oh, itwas beautiful and elegant, and Anatole had seriously outdone himself with the food, as though heâd only been waiting for the Sterns to return home to show us what he was made of. But we ate each course in silence, our silver tinkling on the china.
Christmas Eve with strangers. The Sterns were no doubt mourning their first Christmas without Olivia and Bennett, while Natalie had to live with the fact that her parents didnât love and accept her. And I was left trying to ignore that vision and wondering where my own family was. Investigating Neos, no doubt, but at least they couldâve called.
At the end of the meal, Natalie and I stood to help Celeste clear the plates, but Mrs. Stern waved a hand and said, âThat wonât be necessary.â
Somehow, that long uncomfortable meal had sapped all my strength, so I didnât say anything. Instead, we both sunk into our chairs for another stony ten minutes, while Celeste bustled around us.
âWhatâs up with this? Itâs like youâre miming a Christmas dinner,â a male voice said.
âLukas!â Natalie jumped up at the sight of him in his black down jacket, jeans, and Timberlands, striding into the dining room with a grin on his face. âYouâre back.â
âAnd none too soon.â He took in her outfit. âDid you turn Amish while I was gone?â
âNo, Iâm not Amish, you idiot,â she said, but she didnât sound mad about it and hugged him.
He reluctantly let Natalie go and turned to the Sterns.âIâm sorryâI feel like Iâm interrupting a moment of silence or something.â
âYou must be Lukas,â Mrs. Stern said stiffly. âWeâre Alexandra and John Stern.â
âBennettâs parents.â Lukas glanced at me. â
Excellent
.â
âYup,â I said flatly, but the look I gave Lukas made it clear how much I thought this development sucked.
âRight,â Lukas said, shaking Mr. Sternâs hand. âPleased to meet you. So whereâs Bennett?â
âAway,â Mr. Stern answered shortly.
âWhat are you doing here?â Natalie asked Lukas. âWhat happened with your mom and dad?â
Lukas shook his head. âNothing good. It was like a twenty-car pileup.â
âI understand your parents arenât ghostkeepers,â Mrs. Stern said.
âTheyâre the opposite of ghostkeepers.â Lukas tossed his jacket on a side chair. âTheyâre ghosthaters. At least, I guess they believe me now. They just want me to stop doing it.â
Mr. Stern put his arm around Lukasâs shoulder. âWell, youâre welcome here. Come sit down.â
Natalie and I exchanged glances.