face.
âThis is the first time I have cross-examined anyone sitting on my lap.â
âI should hope that you have neither cross-examined nor done anything else,â I retorted.
âSit up, Maggie. It is a disadvantage not being able to see the witnessâs face.â
âNo fear. Iâm comfortable as I am. What do you want to know?â
âThis is not the way to conduct an inquiry,â said John resignedly. âJust tell me how you came to be with Cruikshank, how and where you left him and at what time. As accurately as you can.â
âYou know how. He took me up to the Hall to see Mr Holland.â
âOf course I know, but Sergeant Billings doesnât. Youâd better pretend Iâm him.â
This struck me as funny.
âIf you start giggling, Maggie, Iâll push you off and make you sit opposite to me in proper questioning style.â
I related all I did that afternoon with the estate agent and how I had left him alone with Mr Holland in the latterâs study while Ursula Mulqueen took me over to the Dower.
âJust a minute,â John interrupted. âWhy didnât Cruikshank go with you? Isnât it customary for the agent to accompany the prospective tenant over a house?â
âHe stopped to speak to Mr Holland.â
âDid he stay of his own accord or was it at Mr Hollandâs request?â
âMr Hollandâs, I fancy. He said something about wanting to have a word with him.â
âHow did Holland sound?â
I thought for a minute. âCurt. He seemed annoyed Cruikshank had not answered an earlier summons.â
âWhat time was this?â
âHalf-past four-ish. I noticed a tea tray on Mr Hollandâs desk. I must have been the best part of an hour with Ursula by the time we walked through the wood, looked at the house and returned. I remember catching a train from Middleburn about a quarter to six.â
âAbout four-thirty,â John nodded in approval. âAnd Cruikshank wasnât there when you got back?â
âNo. Mr Holland was alone in the study. We met Ursulaâs mother in the passage. She took me along.â
âDid Mr Holland make any comment about Cruikshank?â
Again I gave Johnâs question some thought.
âI canât quite remember. I did ask if I should get in touch with Cruikshank to tell him about taking the house, but the Squire said: âNo. Iâll fix it up with him; just see my solicitors.â I think that was all.â
âCruikshank didnât say where he was going after he left the Hall? Not waiting to see you was odd.â
âSo I thought at the time. Evidently the business was not to go through the agent at all. We pay a monthly cheque to Braithwaite, donât we?â
âVery odd,â John said again, frowning. âI wonder why Holland took it out of the agentâs hands.â
âPerhaps things are getting tight and he canât afford a shilling in the pound to an agent,â I suggested.
âYou can guarantee Braithwaite doesnât do it for nothing. No, thereâs something unusual there. Who else was in the house when you left Cruikshank and Holland together?â
âYvonne was. I presume Mrs Mulqueen was too. She came down from upstairs as Ursula and I came in. I donât know the domestic arrangements of the Hall, but I suppose someone was in the kitchen. There was going to be a dinner party that night.â
âIâll suggest to Sergeant Billings to check up on them. What was your impression of Cruikshank when you left him? Was he frightened or ill-at-ease?â
I sat up with a jolt. âYouâre not thinking Mr Holland killed him and buried him in the cellar, are you?â
âDonât be silly,â John said severely. âThese are routine questions. You always ask how the vanished seemed when seen last. He might have lost his memory or something.â
I sank