a look at the lady.â
Big Daveâs widow was a mess. Whichever brother had stabbed her with the hunting-knife letter opener from Big Daveâs desk, he had wielded it with passion and without finesse, many times.
âBut,â as the Inspector remarked, âhe wasnât out for a medal in technique. The things people do for money!â
âWhatâs this?â Ellery had picked up a manâs raincoat with the eraser end of a pencil. The raincoat was slightly damp, the lower part of the right sleeve was rain-soaked, and the front of the coat was smeared untidily and redly. It was of medium size, not new.
âWe found it rolled up under that leather chair,â said the Inspector. âShe fought for her life and he got her blood all over his coat. Rather than risk being caught or even seen with the coat in this condition, he left it here.â
âA bad mistake,â said Ellery.
âYou think so? You wonât find any identifying marks, the pockets were cleaned out even of lint and dust, all three brothers owned raincoats like this at one time or other, and they all wear a medium size. Each one denies itâs his coat, and each one says he canât produce his own coat because he discarded it long ago. So we donât get at him through elimination.â
âThere are other ways,â remarked Ellery.
âYes,â said his father with a shrug, âweâll do a sweat, hair, and dust analysis, but theyâre not always conclusive. I have a hunch, son, we wonât get any more out of the coat than we did out of the knife, which doesnât show a print.â
âI disagree.â
âYou see something I missed?â exclaimed Inspector Queen. âIn the coat?â
âYes, Dad. Something that indicates exactly which brother killed Big Daveâs widow. And with nothing up my sleeve,â said Ellery with a grin, âalthough with something definitely up his .
âLook at this coat. Itâs slightly damp from the rain, but the lower part of the right sleeve is rain- soaked . How did that part of the sleeve get soaked while the rest of the sleeveâin fact, the rest of the coatâmerely got a little damp?
âThe brothers came here separately, at different times, each alone in his car. Itâs rained all day. So the wearer of this coat drove a car in the rain. In driving a car in the rain, especially in city traffic, what do you habitually do which will get one of your coat sleeves wet?â
âGive arm signals for stops and turns â¦!â But then Inspector Queen looked puzzled. âBut the driver always signals with his left arm, Ellery, and itâs the right sleeve of this coat thatâs rain-soaked.â
âConclusion: This driver signalled with his right arm.â
âBut to be able to do thatââ the Inspector stopped. Then he said, slowly, â His car has a righthand drive. â
âCharltonâs Cadillac and Archibaldâs ChevroletâAmerican carsâlefthand drives,â said Ellery, nodding. âBut the other car is a Rolls-RoyceâBritish; and whatâs more, a Rolls bought secondhand in London, so it has to have a righthand drive. Indicating the owner of the RollsâEverett Brothers.
âBy the way, Dad, whatâs he look like?â
PARK PATROL DEPT.
A Lump of Sugar
If not for the fact that Mounted Patrolman Wilkins was doing the dawn trick on the bridle path, where it goes by the Park Tavern, the Shakes Cooney murder would never have been solved. Ellery admits this cheerfully. He can afford to, since it was he who brought to that merry-go-round some much-needed horse sense.
A waiter with a hot date had neglected to strip one of his tables on the Tavernâs open terrace at closing time the night before, whereupon the question was: Who had done a carving job on Cooneyâs so-called heart about 6 A.M. the next morning? Logic said nearly eight