said, âNo. Well . . .â
âWait,â said Violet. âPlease wait. We need your help. We think Spotzie isnât lost after all. We think she was stolen. If you know anything that can help us find her, please tell us!â
The professor hesitated. She half turned, as if she were about to go back inside without answering. Then she turned back around.
âOkay,â she said. âYouâre not the only one looking for a lost cat that matches the picture you showed me. The day before you came over, someone else was here looking for a lost cat. Heâd gotten my name from the animal shelter as someone who had a lot of cats and might have taken his in.â
âWhat happened?â asked Jessie eagerly.
âI showed him the cat I gave to you. He said she was his cat and made a grab for her. She hissed and tried to get away from him. That made me suspicious.â
âWhy would his own cat do that?â Bennyâs eyes were wide.
âI donât think it was his cat.â Professor Madison went on, âI became really suspicious when he offered me a large reward for the cat â a great deal too much money â if Iâd just hand her over. When I wouldnât, he became very angry and almost threatening. I made him leave.
âThat same night, someone tried to break into my house. Fortunately, I have an alarm system and it scared off whoever it was. But Iâm sure it was the same man.â
âIt could be the same man who called us, too,â said Henry.
âWhat are you talking about?â the professor asked.
âLast night, someone called us and told us to stop looking for Spotzie if we knew what was good for us. Thatâs what made us think she was stolen,â Henry explained. âWhat did the man who came here look like?â
Professor Madison answered, âIt was hard to tell. He was wearing a hat and dark glasses and a coat with the collar turned up â almost like a disguise. That made me suspicious, too.â
The Aldens exchanged glances. It sounded like the man who had followed them outside the animal shelter!
âI think youâre right,â Professor Madison continued. âI think it might be the same man that called you.â She reached out and took the photograph of Spotzie that Jessie was holding. âThey do look alike, donât they. But I donât understand it. Why would someone steal a cat like this?â
No one could answer that.
The professor gave the photograph back to Jessie. âAnyway, Iâm glad sheâs in a safe place now. Thatâs why I insisted you take her. I know that man wasnât her owner and I didnât trust him.â
Jessie put the picture carefully in her pocket. âThank you, Professor Madison,â she said.
âGood luck,â said Professor Madison. âIf anything else happens, or I can think of anything to help, Iâll let you know.â
She went back into her house and the Boxcar children went down the stairs and got back on their bicycles.
âWho could have taken Spotzie?â wondered Violet.
âAnd why?â added Jessie.
âThatâs the biggest mystery of all,â said Henry. âSpotzie looks like an ordinary cat.â
âMaybe sheâs not,â said Benny. âMaybe sheâs a rare and valuable cat.â
âOh, Benny,â said Jessie. âSpotzie isnât like those cats we saw at Mr. Allenâs. Those cats are like the dogs we saw at the dog show. They are very valuable.â
âBut Watch isnât a show dog, and heâs valuable,â said Benny.
âThatâs true, Benny,â Violet said. âAnd Spotzie isnât a show cat, but she is valuable to Mr. Woods, too, because he loves her, the same way we love Watch.â
âThat makes Watch and Spotzie the most valuable dog and cat of all,â declared Benny.
âYouâre right,â Violet said to her little