weâre gone?â
âSure thing.â
âAnd maybe start looking for the other tenants,â Jane said. âIf theyâre not in the building, weâll have to find them to reinterview them.â
MacHovec started writing down names. âAs good as done,â he said airily.
Jane wasnât so sure.
âSo youâve got the Quill case.â Charlie Bracken was a big man with dark, graying hair, a gut, and sharp eyes. He was wearing a worn sports jacket, the pockets stretched out of shape, and dark gray pants. He pulled another chair over to the desk. âSit down. Can I get you some coffee?â
They said yes, and Bracken brought three Styrofoam cups back and a handful of sugars and whiteners. Defino put everything in his and stuck a wooden stirrer in it and kept it moving.
âBroke my ass on that case. Looked like a push-in but it didnât feel right. Nothing was taken. Wallet, keys, watch, money. Everything was still there.â He shrugged. âGuy had an uncontested divorce, ex-wife was out of the country when he was killed, coworkers said he was a nice guy, did his job, never said much. Most of âem didnât care much whether he was dead or alive, but no one
wanted
him dead. Other people in the building didnât know he existed.â
âPay his rent on time?â Defino asked.
âNo complaints. His apartment . . . what can I tell you? Not scrubbed clean but everything in place, checkbook up-to-date, food in the fridge, stuff in the freezer, extra rolls of toilet paper in the closet, clean sheets on the bed. Looked like he was planning to stay awhile.â
âAny girlfriends?â Defino asked, and after a moment, âBoyfriends?â
âNah. I got the feeling he hadnât gotten over his wife yet. Sheâs a looker. Met her second husband at work. He also got divorced to marry her.â
âThe other woman remarry?â Jane asked.
âNot at the time of the homicide.â
âThe other tenants,â she said. âThey all clean?â
âAs clean as anyone in New York. There was one guy. . . .â He opened a drawer and took out a dog-eared file folder and opened it. âOn the top floor . . . there was only one tenant on four; the other apartment was emptyâthere was a guy named Hutchins. Something about him. He didnât fit. Came from out west somewhere. Talk to him, he never laid eyes on Arlen Quill.â
Defino said to Jane, âTell him.â
Jane watched Brackenâs face warm with expectation. A detective never lost interest in his old cases. âI went by the house yesterday,â she said. âThe names on the mailboxes were all different. None of the tenants from the time of the homicide are living there.â
Brackenâs eyes narrowed. âCrazy.â
âYeah.â
âThe woman on the first floor, Best is her name, she died maybe six months after Quill. Stroke, I think. She was a funny old gal, wore a black wig with bangs, looked like Mamie Eisenhower. But the others, last time I checked they were all there.â
âWhen was that?â
âSix, eight months after the homicide. I never called any of them again after that.â
âWeâve got someone on our team checking them out,â Defino said. âWe need to reinterview them if we can find them.â
âFour people moved out in four years,â Bracken said. âRent-controlled building. Doesnât make sense.â
âThatâs what we thought.â
âMakes you wonder. I didnât hear anything bad about the landlord. He owns a bunch of buildings on the West Side. No complaints about heat, no fights that I heard about. He sure as hell didnât move his family into Quillâs apartment. I even went up to a couple of his other buildings and asked around. Nothing.â
âSounds like you did a thorough job,â Jane said.
âSo why did they move? Donât