plans he had and do his work. But it was apparent that Don, an older gentleman, had died of natural causes. Putting him in the cooler and waiting until Monday morning was not going to hurt anything. On top of that, what did his family want?
The one injury Ortiz-Reyes noticed as he wound down his hasty examination was on Donâs right eye. He had âan old injuryâ there. Probably two days old, the doctor later noted.
The one thing Ortiz-Reyes was obligated to do was come up with a preliminary finding; in other words, he needed to spend enough time with the body in order to determine a cause of death that he could put before the medical examiner on the death certificate, which the medical examiner would then have to sign off on.
Taken into account all Ortiz-Reyes had heard from responding officers and the OCME investigator sent to the scene, Ortiz-Reyes was comfortable with not proceeding with a formal autopsy on this dayâi.e., cutting Don open and examining his innards, weighing organs, cutting open his brain with a buzz saw and initiating the lab to begin testing samples of tissue. Lab workers would come in early Monday, and if they werenât facing a backlog, they would test Donâs blood and urine just to make sure there was nothing out of the ordinary as far as poisons or anything else that might cause alarm.
âWhen we have a body . . . [and] nothing out of the natural is related to the death of this person,â Ortiz-Reyes explained later, âwe usually see the body to check for any kind of injuries. If everything is within the normal, we donât do autopsy.â Furthermore, Ortiz-Reyes added, because of Donâs age being in the neighborhood âwhere most Americans die of heart problems, I thought he had died of heart problems.â
As Ortiz-Reyes stood over Don, still taking notes, thinking about the situation and all of the factors involved, he told himself, There is no need for an autopsy. He then reflected, This gentleman more likely died of problems in the heart . . . arteriosclerotic cardiovascular disease, meaning that the heartâthat the vessels around the heart are in bad shape and do not give enough blood to the heart to support the life.
It was an educated guess, based on Ortiz-Reyesâs experience.
Generally, when a medical examiner thinks a human being died of a heart attack, the first thing he or she does is open that person up and have a look at the heart. But because Don was so old, by Ortiz-Reyesâs swift estimation, he didnât feel the need to do that, at least not on this day.
Ortiz-Reyes took a sample of urine and blood from Donâs body. He posted them to the lab for examination on Monday when they came back from the weekend.
âHeart attack,â Ortiz-Reyes later said in court that he thought at that moment.
There wasnât a doubt in his mind.
Ortiz-Reyes took one last look at Donâs body, finished his notes and told the weekend staff Don needed to be put in the cooler.
He then shut off the lights in the autopsy suite and left.
CHAPTER 8
VONLEE NICOLE TITLOW DECIDED to head back to North Carolina to pick up her new car, and then head home to Tennessee, where her former life was waiting for her. She could walk into the Waffle House and ask for her job back. She could explain she fell off the wagon and that she was now working with a clean slate and a clear head. Sheâd go back to AA. Sheâd clean up her life. It was a bump in the road. Everyone deserved a second chance.
The one lesson Vonlee took away from her time in Michigan with her aunt was that âI was seeing for the first time how Billie Jean wasnât the sweetheart that I had always thought she was.â
Back in Tennessee as the middle of July 2000 came around, and Billie Jean was home in Michigan with her son, Vonlee went to see Billie Jeanâs sister, her other aunt. She sat down and had coffee and explained what happened in Michigan