utterance of that simple monosyllable. And the pain is not undone by his continuing, âBut I havenât seen her for three years at least.â
âYou seem to know a lot about her kids ...â My heart is galloping now: a wounded runaway horse.
â I spoke to her while you were in Chicago.â
âOh.â I am overcome; I stare hard at him, obviously getting pleasure from his own revelation. Seven years ago! Three years ago! This is ridiculous. Ancient history. Why should it come between us now?
âDid you love her? Whenever you mention her name, I feel you still love her ...â
Bennett hedges: âWhatâs love?â
âWhen you speak of someoneâs kids in that tone of voice.â I am choking on my words. My salad sits on my plate dying in its vinegar. âYou never speak of me in that tone of voice.â
Bennett shrugs.
âYou loved her, didnât you?â I hate the sound of my voice, saying this. So plaintive, so betrayed.
âWhy does that matter?â
âThat means the answer is yes.â
He shrugs again.
âOh come on, Bennett, tell me. Itâs worse if you hedge like that. At least you loved someone if you didnât love me.... At least you loved ...â
âDonât raise your voice like that. People know who you are...â
âAnd why not?â I scream. âI donât care who knows. I really donât.â
âShut up,â Bennett says, his voice a steel trap.
Â
Later, in the car going back to New York (what point is there staying in Woodstock when the purpose for our trip has already been fulfilled?), I interrogate him about Penny, that cold copper bitch. I hear myself sounding just like a betrayed wife in a novel-and I hate it. But Iâm unable to stop. Some demon speaks through my mouth while my body looks on, amazed, ashamed.
âHow often did you see her?â
âI donât remember.â
âHow can you not remember?â
âI just canât.â
I think of my two part-time lovers (both of them named Jeffrey) who seem totally irrelevant to my life, but still I can remember everything. Every meeting, every meal, every mouthful.
Â
âWas she good in bed?â
âI refuse to go into detail.â
âWas she?â
Bennett hesitates. He has unleashed something he cannot now control. He wants to take it all back. Salvage begins.
âI donât think she ever came. She moaned and writhed a lot, but I think she was inorgastic.â
Inorgastic. I recognize the voice of Dr. Herschel W. Steingesser prompting from behind the couch.
âHow did you know?â
âI never knew for sure.â
âDidnât you care?â
âLook, Isadora, not all women are like you. Some of them get a lot out of sex without coming. They like being held, stroked, fondled.â
Snidely: âTell me about all those other women.â
âThere werenât any others.â
âSure.â
âItâs true. There was just Penny. I felt I was dying and she saved my life. It was mostly that I needed someone to talk to. I couldnât talk to you in those days.â
âSaved your life? Thatâs pretty strong stuff. Weâd only been married a year. Why didnât you leave me if you felt so trapped? I was miserable too. It might have been a blessing.â
âBecause I was conflicted. I knew you were warm and cuddly. That you came and she didnât, that my need for her was probably all my unresolved oedipal problem ...â
âThat word again.â
Bennett bristles: âLookâdo you want to hear or donât you?â
âI do. I do.â
âShe had six childrenâlike my mother-and a husband she hated. I saw her as a damsel in distressâthe mother I could save ...â
âI thought she saved you.â
âIt was mutual.â
âIt sounds great. It sounds like you should have gotten