rummaged through the kitchen counter of my friendâs apartment, looking for something to eat, I spotted the empty bottle of Negroamaro. I thought, âThatâs pretty black of you, Baratunde.â
As with most of my thoughts, I decided this was something I should share with the Internet, so I fired up the Twitter app on my phone and instigated a battle of blackness with my friend and fellow Brooklyn-based comedian Elon James White.
On Wednesday, July 29, 2009, at 7:32 a.m., I pressed âsendâ on the following message:
this weekend i picked my red wine because it was called âNegroamaro.â thatâs how black i am. @elonjames #HowBlackAreYou
Two minutes later, Elon responded, âChallenge, son?â and it was on. For the next several hours, we went back and forth trying to prove our blackness in a game of satirical one-upmanship. Others saw the #HowBlackAreYou hashtag flying across their screens and decided to join in. Before long, thousands of #HowBlackAreYou tweets had been generated.
I later retold this story in a technology conference keynote address called âThereâs a #Hashtag for That,â and got the attention of an editor at HarperCollins. After I met with her and her team, the title âHow to Be Blackâ was born. I thought an entire book on âHow Black Are You?â was a bit much. (But âHow to Be Blackâ felt just fine!)
Still, that original question interests me. It is an inextricable fact of blackness that one will at some point be referred to as âtoo blackâ or ânot black enoughâ by white people, black people, and others. Iâve yet to meet the Negro who is âjuuuuuust rightâ to everyone. So I turned the question over to The Black Panel. Hereâs some of what they had to say in answer to the question âHow black are you?â
W. KAMAU BELL
I guess we need to know whoâs on the scale. I would probably say Iâm in the middle. Iâd say Iâm solidly in the middle. I think Iâve spent most of my life in the middle of blackness, maybe just north of the middle as Iâve gotten older. I think I get more reason to be black the older I get.
Itâs like everything. The older you get, the more you get calcified in whatever direction you were going in. I feel about racism the way a lot of guys feel about male-pattern baldness. âThis was supposed to be done by now!â Which makes me more black, like âOkay, then Iâm going to really step up my game, my black game.â
CHERYL CONTEE
Iâm pretty black on the inside. That said, genetically, itâs obvious thereâs a little bit of a mix here. And thatâs something that Iâve gotten to know over time more extensively through the oral histories of my family, very quietly learning the large extent to which people actually chose to live in the black community to be with the people that they love, which is really awesome and amazing. So I do pay homage to those other heritages, but I feel very much, very strongly, rooted in African-American culture.
That said, I think that there is a stereotype that youâre not really black unless you grew up dodging bullets, or eating food stamps, or . . . I donât know, actually engaging personally in rap battles or break dancing. I didnât do any of those things. I may have witnessed some break dancing and some rap battles. Okay, that may have happened. But I didnât personally do that.
Sorry, eating . . . Did I say that, eating food stamps?
ELON JAMES WHITE
How black am I? It depends on the day of the week. It depends on who you ask. It depends on what situation Iâm in. It depends on if my white girlfriend shows up. It depends on what topic happens to pop up.
Iâm fairly black to people. Iâve gotten blacker. Like, I wasnât that black for a while, but then I got really, really black. And apparently when I got really black,