anything Little Willie John had set in motion. Lee had been a big band singer for Will Osborne and Benny Goodman and was famous as the voice of Darling in Disneyâs Lady and the Tramp (1955). Luxurious in her passivity, she turned âFeverâ into a steam bath, but her flirtation was all ladylike finesse; she purred where John growled, and her finger snaps had all the crackle of milquetoast. For the length of Leeâs single, which included several painfully self-conscious key changes, it seemed as though Tin Pan Alley might actually tame the beast. But Lee never had another top ten hit. Paul McCartney was a fan, but Leeâs image was all risqué controlâher next biggest record, âIs That All There Is?â in 1969, worked as a coda to many a one-hit wonder, including herself.
Ironically, Presley covered âFeverâ more as a nod to Lee than Little Willie John, but that was just the Memphis boy in him who yearned to be Dean Martin. Presley did away with the key changes (wisely) and sounded drunk on his own restraint. Like Little Willie John, an anxious quietude hovers over Presleyâs take. There were worlds in Presleyâs pauses, and the sustained tension only underlined its seething contradictions (weakness as strength). At best, this âFeverâ was heartache, a yearning for something the singer feared might elude him; at its worst, it was the most damning feeling a man could carry, a measure of his capacity to feel. Elsewhere, you can measure Presleyâs success in his cohortsâ different slants on manhood: Presleyâs rock ânâ roll man was a metaphor for freedom and new male identities, not a new rigid code. If anything, Presleyâs more provocative peers worked out the feminine side of masculinity, peacocking insecurities, vulnerabilities, and sexual eccentricity when they lacked Presleyâs striking good looks.
Little Richard was the most flamboyant of these performers. His bouffant hairdo anticipated the Afro, and he tossed his head back with the illicit thrill of a gay man passing as a mere eccentric in a straight manâs club. Suburban Eisenhower culture in the 1950s was so sexually occluded that it accepted Richard as a kind of oddity, just another weird twist in the new teen craze. But Richardâs persona drew on lyrics transparently trimmed of explicit come-ons even before they suggested homosexuality (âWell, long tall Sallyâs built pretty sweet/Sheâs got everything that Uncle John needsâ¦â), and his singing was so good he managed to distract attention from his beehive and Vegas showgirl makeup. In retrospect, itâs nothing less than astounding that Little Richard broke through, essentially as a novelty, in January of 1956 (just before Presley had his first national hit), with âTutti Frutti.â He threw in manic falsetto âWhoo!â at every turn, and âLong Tall Sallyâ was heard as âWop-Bop-A-Luâ gibberish when it was really code for God Knows What.
Buddy Holly presented another kind of man: one who got up his nerve with women only through song. Holly turned John Wayneâs dismissive tag line from The Searchers (âThatâll be the dayâ) into a triumphant rock catchphrase, a world of revenge hurled at a suspicious lover, and John Lennonâs favorite song. Consider the conceit: Holly, the wire-framed nerd, found something in Wayneâs bigoted Ethan Edwards to call his ownâsomething that reduced that oversized characterâs blind hatred into a retort that boomeranged with affection. Holly hiccuped coyly, as if barely containing all the terror of changing from a boy into a man. Physically, he was a geek with glasses, but as a writer he held his own with Chuck Berry, Jerry Lieber and Ed Stoller (âHound Dogâ), Mort Shuman and Doc Pomus (âHis Latest Flameâ), and Willie Dixon (âWang Dang Doodleâ). A song like âPeggy