Weâre talking maybe eleven hundred people max, and most of âem have been here since the year zip. Anyway, she and Bailey started running around together just like they did before. He says she was dallying with this other guy, involved in some affair that she was being real tight-lipped about. Claims she never would say who it was.
âThe night she was killed, the two of âem went out drinking. Hit about six bars in San Luis and two more in Pismo. Around midnight, they came back and parked down at the beach. He says it was closer to ten, but a witness puts âem there at midnight. Anyway, she was upset. They had a bottle and a couple of joints with âem. They had a tiff and he says he left her there and stomped off. Next thing he knows, itâs morning and heâs in his room at the Ocean Street. These kids are swarming all over the beach down below, doing clean-up detail as part of some local church do-good project. Heâs sick as a dog . . . so hung over he was pukinâ his guts out. Sheâs still down on the beach, passed out over by the stairs . . . only when the clean-up crew gets close, they can see sheâs dead, strangled with a belt that turns out to be his.â
âBut anybody could have done it.â
âAbsolutely. Of course, Bailey was favored and they might have made it stick, but De Witt had had a string of wins and he didnât want to take a chance. Lehto saw an opportunity to bargain and since Baileyâd been burned once, he went along with the deal. On the armed robbery, he was guilty, went to trial, and got himself nailed. This time he claimed he was innocent, but he didnât like the odds so when they offered him a plea of manslaughter, he took it, just like that.â Clemson snapped his fingers, the sound like the clean popping of a hollow stick.
âCould he have beaten the murder rap if heâd gone to trial?â
âHey, who knows? Going to trial is a crapshoot. You put your money on the line every time. If you roll that seven or eleven, boy, youâre feeling good. But if it comes out two, three, or twelve, youâre the loser. The case generated a lot of publicity. Sentiment in town was running against him. Then you had Baileyâs prior, no character witnesses to speak of. He was better off with the deal. Twenty years ago, he couldâve been given the death penalty, too, which is something you donât want to mess with if you can help it. Talk about rolling dice.â
âI thought if you were charged with murder, they wouldnât reduce that.â
âTrue, hypothetically, but thatâs not the way it works. It was just discretionary with the district attorney how he filed. What Lehto did was, he goes to De Witt and says, âLook, George, Iâve got evidence my guy was under the influence at the time. Evidence from your own people.â He pulls out the police report. âIf youâll note in the record, when the officers arrested him, it states he appeared to be drowsy . . .â Blah, blah, blah. Clifford does this whole number and he can see George start to sweat. Heâs got his ego on the line and he doesnât want to go into court with a big hole in his case. As DA, youâre expected to win ninety percent of the time, if not higher.â
âSo Bailey pleaded guilty to the manslaughter and the judge maxed him out,â I said.
âExactly. You got it, but weâre only talkinâ six years. Big deal. With time served and time off for good behavior,he might have been out in half that. The whole time, Fowlerâs thinking he got screwed, but he doesnât understand how lucky he was. Clifford Lehto did a hell of a job for him. Iâd have done the same thing myself.â
âWhat happens next?â
Clemson shrugged again, stubbing out his cigarette. âDepends on how Bailey wants to plead on the felony escape. Whatâs he gonna say,