with a new mania. Gilbert and Sullivanâs H.M.S. Pinafore spread like a contagion from the Fifth Avenue Theater in New York to the Adelphi in San Francisco, infecting thousands of community stages in between. There were childrenâs productions, Catholic versions, Yiddish translations, all-male and all-black and minstrel performances. Suddenly everyone was whistling âWe sail the ocean blue,â or humming âPoor little Buttercup.â Just say the word ânever,â and youâd be drawn into the patter. âWhat, never?â âNo, never!â âWhat, never ?â âWell . . . hardly ever!â
When the Pauline Markham Pinafore Troupe arrived in San Francisco, it didnât take much persuasion to get Mrs. Hirsch to accompany Dora, Agnes, and Sadie to a childrenâs half-price matinée. Once was enough for Evelyn Hirsch, but the girls were enthralled and begged to see the operetta again and again. All of them were stagestruck, but when Agnes revealed that Tommy Tucker the Cabin Boy was played by a girl, Sadie was lost.
âYou mean sheâs wearing trousers? Like Bernhardt ? Agnes, are you sure?â
âI most certainly am.â
âIn grand opera,â Dora informed them, âitâs called a Hosenrolle âa young man played by a contralto in breeches.â
Dora could be a know-it-all.
The next time they went to the theater, Sadie watched for a telltale jiggle beneath the cabin boyâs blue jacket that might give a girl away during the sailorâs hornpipe. The dancer seemed a bit heavier than when the operetta opened two weeks earlier, but Sadie still couldnât believe it.
âAgnes, youâre wrong,â she whispered. âThatâs a boy.â
âYouâll see soon enough. Tommy Tucker is . . .â Agnes dropped her voice and leaned over to say, â . . . en famille.â A lady one row back hissed at them, so Agnes waited a moment before murmuring, âPauline told me so.â
âPauline? You meanâ?â
âMiss Markham, yes. I met her at a party.â Ignoring the insistent âShhh!â behind them, Agnes bestowed her most momentous news in a dramatic whisper. âTheyâre casting for a new cabin boy at the end of the San Francisco run.â
SNEAKING MONEY FROM THE BAKERY TILL and skipping school, Sadie returned to the theater twice more that week to check the choreography. Locked in the bakery storeroom, she practiced the hornpipe madly. When she wasnât hopping on one foot or hauling on imaginary ropes or giving charming nautical salutes, she was upstairs in her room, gazing into a hand mirror and working on her âMysterious and Tragic but Courageousâ expression, while making up a story about being an orphan whose lifelong dream was to join the Pauline Markham troupe and travel the world to earn the applause of audiences everywhereânonsense that rattled right out of her head the moment she stepped through the stage door at the Adelphi.
Surrounded by a chaos of packing crates, costumes, props, and rolled-up canvas scenery, she waited to be noticed, which she was, butmostly by stagehands who shouted at her to get the hell out of the way.
âHebe?â a refined baritone asked curiously.
She turned, offended. âI beg your pardon!â
âWhat part are you auditioning for? Cousin Hebe? The Captainâs Daughter? Surely not Dick Deadeye.â
She needed a moment to recognize him. The First Lord of the Admiralty was a pompous old man, and sheâd paid little attention to that character. Without the ruddy makeup, the admiralâs costume, and talc-whitened hair, the actor was much younger than she would have imagined. He had a gallant bearing and tawny leonine hair sweeping back from the kind of forehead sheâd learned to call âloftyâ from reading novels.
âCome, child! We sail upon the tide! No time to