noticed me.
Oh my God! Imagine running into you here. Too fake.
Itâs been so long! Why not hang a âLook at my crowâs feetâ sign around my neck?
How are you? Maybe. Save it as a last resort.
Are you married? Definitely not.
I think of you every year on your birthday. Swallow fatal amount of sleeping pills before uttering these humiliating words.
As pitiful as it seemsâeven to meâit was true that every year for the past fourteen, I remembered Mattâs birthday. Perhaps it was because the first time we slept together was on his twenty-second birthday, our fourth night together in Fort Lauderdale. The day before, Iâd driven to town with Olivia, Libby, Cindy and Eve to stock up on alcohol and purchase a small cake for Mattâs birthday. Iâd negotiated use of the hotel room until two that morning and planned to invite Matt over in the evening for cake and Jack Danielâs. At midnight, I would be the first person to wish him a happy birthday. That was the plan.
At around eight-thirty, I got a call from Libby. She was at the guysâ hotel room and whispered, âYouâd better call Matt.â
âWhy? We agreed to get together later. Whatâs up?â
âOlivia and I have been here for a few hours, and Eve and Cindy just walked in. Matt thinks youâre blowing him off.â
âWhy are Eve and Cindy there? I thought they were going for a walk.â
âLook out the window.â Pouring rain. âThis was the closest place they could run for shelter. Anyway, Matt is doing a really bad job at trying to act like he doesnât care, but we can all see heâs bummed out âcause he thinks youâre avoiding him.â
âYouâre kidding!â I exclaimed. After just four days I could already see that unshakable apathy was very much part of the persona Matt had cultivated. Even though it was clear he liked me, heâd still pepper his conversations with âwhatever.â I couldnât help feeling just a bit giddy with the fact that he was showing visible signs of actually caring about me.
âPut him on the phone,â I told Libby.
âNo way. Heâd kill me if he knew I called you. You call back here in a few minutes.â
Blowing him off? I laughed. If he only knew I was actually writing his name in blue icing on a supermarket birthday cake.
âHey, are we still on for tonight?â I asked Matt when I called back.
âHey Prudence,â he said coolly. âWhereâve you been all day?â
âWell actually Iâve been shopping for birthday stuff for you. I thought we could celebrate together.â
âShit,â he said.
âWhat an ingrate,â I teased.
âNo, itâs not that. Thank you, no, thank you really. Itâs just, well, when I didnât hear from you, I thought, you know. I thought you were, you made other plans so I told my buddies weâd go out drinking. I shouldâve called. Shit. I fucked up. Okay, how âbout this? Why donât I come over now and then Iâll go out with my friends later?â
I didnât love the plan, but I was already completely in love with him so I accepted it. I rationalized that this would be an opportunity to show him what a cool girlfriend I would be.
He arrived a few minutes before nine in an orange mesh football jersey over a white T-shirt, and crisp 501 jeans. His brown hair was wet and combed neatly in a side part. At the door, he smiled so powerfully it seemed to have the ability to swing the door wide open all by itself.
âHey,â he said. His head moved from one side of the room to the other as he scanned the rainbow of balloons strewn across the floor, and his cake on the table.
âHi. Come on in,â I said, trying to seem very okay with how the evening was turning out. In reality, I was a bit embarrassed that Iâd gone through all this trouble for a fifteen-minute round of drinks