donât let things rest, Cade,â she said.
âI know you donât,â he said.
Jonathan put his arm around Morgan. âCade, I want to see that gun.â
âIâm sorry, Jonathan. Itâs evidence in a homicide case.â
âWell, then Iâm going with McCormick to show him where mine is. Iâll take Morgan with me.â
âYou canât go, Jonathan,â Cade said.
Jonathan gaped at him. âWhat do you mean, I canât go?â
âI need you here,â he said. âWe may need to ask you more questions.â
âYou know where to find me,â Jonathan told him. âYou can call me at home and ask me.â
âJonathan, youâre not going anywhere.â
âWhy not?â Jonathan asked again. âCade, whatâre you saying?â
Cade stood eye to eye with him, unmoving. âIâm saying that if you try to leave, Iâll have to arrest you.â
He went back into the warehouse, and Jonathan stood there, his mouth openâfeeling as if nothing in his world made sense any more.
Â
Â
I t wasnât long before McCormick was back at the warehouse with the news. The door to the toolshed was wide open, and Jonathan Clearyâs speargun wasnât there.
That wasnât what Cade wanted to hear. He had hoped McCormick would tell him that the gun was right where Jonathan kept it. Heâd already heard back from Billy Caldwell, who was at the station with the other three spearfishermen. Heâd found each of their guns and brought them in with them. Another officer had checked with every sports store in town. Only one sold spearguns, mostly through catalog orders. He hadnât sold any Blue Water Magnums.
Jonathanâs was still the only one they knew of on the island.
âWant me to read him his rights?â McCormick asked.
Cade couldnât conceive of locking up his friend. He tried to think through the possibilities. Someone had taken the gun out of the shed and used it to kill Thelma and Wayne. Then they had left it at the scene so the police would find it. Maybe they wanted it to look like Jonathan had done it.
Or maybe there was someone else on the island who had one, or one of the transient seamen, or a psychotic tourist. . . .
Maybe Jonathan had just misplaced his gun. . . .
Or maybe the most obvious possibility was the truthâthat Jonathan had gotten so angry at them that he had acted in a fit of rage, hardly knowing what he was doing. . . .
But Cade had known Jonathan for years, had grown up with him, played baseball and football with him. They had gone to college together, and Cade had been best man in Jonathanâs wedding. He knew his friend to be a good person, one who didnât have murder in his heart. Could some set of circumstances have conspired to push Jonathan into a lethal rage?
If there was a possibility, even a remote one, that Jonathan might have done this, Cade had to lock him up. He had no choice.
For the first time since his uncle, the mayor, had appointed him chief of police, he wished he had found another vocation.
âTell me what to do, and Iâll do it,â McCormick said.
âIâll take care of it,â Cade said. He looked across the warehouse to the open door. Through it, he could see Blair, sitting out on that bench, looking so strong and angry, when inside he knew she was falling apart. And sweet Morgan, still clinging to her husband, shivering from the shock. She would accuse Cade of using Jonathan as a scapegoat. She would claim that he was trying to look effective by making an arrestâany arrestâso the people of the town wouldnât panic. Would she be right?
But Jonathan owned the murder weapon, and heâd had that fight with his in-laws earlier that day. He was a hothead, always had been. He flew off the handle at the slightest thing. Maybe today heâd gotten too angry . . . gone too far . . .
If he could just get